Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Dayton, OH
Wagner Insurance has been independently owned and locally operated for four generations, providing tailored insurance solutions across Ohio and surrounding states. Our agency was founded on the principles of integrity and trust by Robert P. Wagner Sr., whose legacy continues through our commitment to personalized service. We work closely with families, business owners, and HR departments, prioritizing client needs over simple product sales. Our team brings decades of industry experience, offering expert guidance to help clients make informed decisions about their coverage. We partner with multiple reputable insurance carriers to provide diverse options for auto, home, life, business, and specialty insurance needs. Our offices in Dayton, West Milton, and Lebanon serve as hubs for community-focused service, treating every client like family.We emphasize transparency in all communications, ensuring clients understand their policy details and coverage limitations. Our service philosophy extends beyond policy issuance to include ongoing support for claims resolution and coverage adjustments. With expertise in niche markets like aircraft products and religious organizations insurance, we handle complex cases other agencies might decline. Our digital tools enable convenient policy management, including payments, ID card orders, and coverage changes. We maintain affiliations with professional organizations like the Independent Insurance Agents Association to stay at the forefront of industry standards. Through four generations of family leadership, we've preserved our founding commitment to client-centric service in an evolving insurance landscape.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Medicare Plans
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Flood Insurance
Commercial Auto
Employee Benefits
Highlights and features
- We have been serving clients for over 4 generations with proven expertise.
- We offer personalized insurance solutions tailored to your specific needs.
- Our team provides expert guidance through complex insurance decision-making processes.
- We maintain partnerships with multiple top-rated insurance carriers for diverse options.
- We provide specialized coverage for hard-to-place insurance requirements.
Associations and certifications
- Independent Insurance Agents Association
- Professional Insurance Agents
- Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC)
What people say
Excellent service
Prompt claims handling
Best service
Great company
Efficient and prompt
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance specialists help Ohio drivers find affordable policies with comprehensive protection. We compare rates from multiple carriers to ensure proper coverage for your vehicle type and driving history. Our policies include liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options with flexible deductibles.
Home Insurance
We provide customized homeowner insurance solutions that protect against common risks while meeting individual budget requirements. Our policies cover structural damage, personal belongings, and liability protection with options for flood and earthquake coverage. We help clients understand policy details and coverage limitations.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance services protect Ohio companies with tailored risk management solutions. We offer general liability, property insurance, and specialized coverage for unique industries including religious organizations and artisan contractors. Policies help safeguard against common business risks and operational disruptions.
Life Insurance
We offer term and universal life insurance policies to provide financial protection for your loved ones. Our advisors help clients choose appropriate coverage amounts and policy types based on individual circumstances and long-term financial goals. Policies help maintain family financial stability in case of unexpected events.
Medicare Plans
Our certified Medicare specialists help seniors navigate complex coverage options with personalized plan comparisons. We explain Part A, B, C, and D differences and help identify the most cost-effective options based on prescription needs and preferred providers. Services include annual plan reviews and updates.
People
Robert P. Wagner Sr.
Founder
Founded Wagner Insurance with a commitment to integrity and client-focused service. Established the family legacy of honest business practices that continues through four generations of leadership.
Pete Purcell
Health Advisor
Certified Medicare specialist with 18 years of experience helping seniors navigate insurance options. Provides personalized plan comparisons and annual coverage reviews to ensure optimal protection for changing healthcare needs.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, business, Medicare, boat, motorcycle, flood, commercial, and specialty insurance policies through multiple carriers.
How do you help find the right policy?
Our agents compare rates and coverage options from multiple insurers to find personalized solutions matching your specific protection needs and budget.
Which areas do you serve?
We operate from Dayton, West Milton, and Lebanon, Ohio offices and provide coverage throughout Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, Indiana, and four additional southeastern states.
How do I file a claim?
Contact your insurance carrier directly or reach out to our office for assistance navigating the claims process with your specific insurance provider.
Can I manage policies online?
Yes, our service center allows online payments, policy changes, ID card requests, and certificate of insurance orders through our secure digital platform.
Do you offer specialized insurance?
We provide niche coverage for unique needs including aircraft products, religious organizations, and artisan contractors through specialized insurance programs.
Videos
