Business Details
47 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Waukesha, WI
Carrigan Insurance has been serving clients since 1979, founded by Joe Carrigan who began his career with American Family Insurance before establishing an independent agency. Our team includes Joe's son Max and Customer Service Representative Tina, combining decades of industry experience with personalized service. We represent over a dozen top-rated insurance companies, including Auto-Owners, Acuity, and Progressive, to provide competitive coverage options. Our approach focuses on building long-term relationships through transparency, reliability, and tailored solutions for auto, home, business, and specialty insurance needs.With two Wisconsin locations in Waukesha and Fontana, we prioritize accessibility and prompt assistance for policy management and claims support. Client testimonials highlight our responsiveness, cost-saving expertise, and family-oriented service philosophy. We emphasize understanding individual client needs to deliver value-driven insurance strategies while maintaining community-focused business practices.
Services
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Small Business Insurance
Renters Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
RV Insurance
Watercraft Insurance
Condo Insurance
Bond Services
Details
- Year established: 1979
Highlights and features
- We offer 45+ years of combined insurance expertise since 1979
- Our team represents 12+ top-rated insurance carriers for competitive options
- We provide personalized policy comparisons to maximize savings
- Family-run business with direct access to agents during operating hours
- Quick claims assistance through established carrier relationships
What people say
Always available
Best rates possible
Quick response times
Family-oriented service
Decades of expertise
Services
Car Insurance
We provide comprehensive car insurance solutions tailored to individual driving profiles and vehicle needs. Our policies protect against accidents, theft, and weather damage while offering liability coverage for responsible drivers. With access to multiple carriers, we help clients find competitive rates that match their specific requirements.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance policies safeguard residential properties against fire, natural disasters, and liability claims. We offer customizable coverage options for standard homes, condos, and rental properties while ensuring policyholders understand their protection limits and deductible choices.
Small Business Insurance
We create tailored insurance packages for Wisconsin businesses, including liability protection, property coverage, and specialized policies for unique operations. Our approach considers industry-specific risks while balancing affordability with comprehensive protection for growing enterprises.
Umbrella Insurance
We offer umbrella insurance policies that provide additional liability coverage beyond standard auto and home policies. These plans protect clients from major claims or lawsuits by extending coverage limits while coordinating with existing insurance policies.
Motorcycle Insurance
Our motorcycle insurance provides coverage for various bike types while addressing unique riding risks. We offer customizable policies that protect against accidents, theft, and weather damage while helping riders maintain compliance with Wisconsin's insurance requirements.
People
Joe Carrigan
Founder
Started in insurance in 1979, transitioned to independent agency in 1989, and built relationships with multiple carriers to provide competitive coverage options for Wisconsin residents.
Max Carrigan
Agent
Joined family business after gaining industry experience, now provides insurance solutions while maintaining client relationships through personalized service and policy expertise.
Tina Groth
Customer Service Representative
Assists clients with policy management and claims processing, known for attentive service and commitment to helping customers find cost-effective insurance solutions.
Questions
How do you help clients find the best insurance rates?
We compare policies across 12+ top-rated carriers to find competitive pricing while maintaining appropriate coverage levels for each client's specific needs.
What insurance types do you specialize in?
We provide auto, home, business, motorcycle, RV, watercraft, and umbrella insurance with expertise in both personal and commercial coverage solutions.
How does your claims process work?
We assist clients through the claims process by coordinating with insurance carriers, explaining policy coverage details, and ensuring timely resolution of claims.
Do you serve businesses as well as individuals?
Yes, we offer specialized insurance packages for small businesses including liability protection, property coverage, and industry-specific policies for Wisconsin companies.
Are you available for after-hours emergencies?
While we maintain standard business hours, we prioritize urgent client needs through callback arrangements and emergency contact protocols for critical situations.
Videos
