Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Key West, FL
Since 1891, The Porter Allen Company has been a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions in Key West and the Florida Keys. As an independent insurance agency, we represent multiple carriers to offer clients personalized service, competitive pricing, and tailored coverage options. Our dedicated team of licensed agents prioritizes one-on-one client relationships, ensuring that both personal and commercial insurance needs are met with expertise and care. With over a century of experience, we remain committed to educating the Florida community about risk management and insurance solutions. Our focus on local market knowledge, combined with access to top-rated insurance providers, allows us to deliver exceptional service to residents and businesses across the Florida Keys.

We specialize in auto, home, flood, commercial property, business liability, and specialized insurance products, adapting to evolving client needs while maintaining our founding principles of integrity and customer-centric service. Through our streamlined claims process and 24/7 emergency support, we ensure prompt assistance when it matters most. Our agency's longevity reflects our ability to combine traditional values with modern insurance solutions, making us a reliable partner for protecting what matters most to our clients.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Flood Insurance Commercial Property Business Liability Workers Compensation Church Insurance Condo Insurance Landlord Insurance Personal Umbrella
Highlights and features
  • We have over 130 years of experience serving Florida's insurance needs
  • Our independent agency status provides access to multiple carrier options
  • Dedicated team offers personalized service with local market expertise
  • 24/7 claim reporting available for emergency situations
  • Specialized coverage options for both personal and commercial clients
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions tailored to individual needs. Our policies protect against liability, collision, and various road risks while offering customizable coverage options. With access to multiple carriers, we help clients find competitive rates and appropriate protection levels for their vehicles and driving habits.
Commercial Property
Our commercial property insurance protects business assets against fire, theft, and natural disasters. Coverage includes buildings, equipment, inventory, and essential business assets. We work with clients to assess risks and create customized policies that safeguard their commercial investments in Key West and surrounding areas.
Flood Insurance
We offer specialized flood insurance policies to protect properties in Florida's coastal areas. Coverage includes structural damage and personal property losses from flooding events. Our experts help clients understand flood zone requirements and secure appropriate protection through the National Flood Insurance Program and private carriers.
Business Owners Policy
Our Business Owners Policies combine property, liability, and business interruption coverage into comprehensive packages. Tailored for small to mid-sized businesses, these policies protect against common risks while offering cost-effective solutions. We help clients customize coverage based on industry-specific needs and operational exposures.
Workers Compensation
We provide workers' compensation insurance to protect businesses and employees from work-related injuries and illnesses. Our policies meet Florida's legal requirements while offering comprehensive coverage for medical expenses and lost wages. We assist businesses in managing workplace risks and navigating the claims process efficiently.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer personal insurance (auto, home, flood) and commercial insurance (property, liability, workers' comp) for clients in Key West and the Florida Keys.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote online through our website or call us at 305-294-2542 for a personalized consultation with our insurance professionals.
Do you handle insurance claims?
Yes, we provide 24/7 claim reporting assistance and support throughout the claims process with dedicated agent guidance.
Are you licensed in Florida?
Yes, we are a licensed insurance agency in Florida with over 130 years of experience serving local communities.
Can you help with specialized insurance needs?
Yes, we offer specialized coverage for churches, restaurants, contractors, and other niche industries through our network of top-rated carriers.