Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Sunbury, Ohio
Payne & Brown Insurance has been fostering valued relationships with clients since 1965, starting from our hometown Sunbury office. Our agency has grown to serve seven Ohio locations, offering personalized insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. As an independent, multi-carrier agency, we prioritize superior service and quality coverage from trusted carriers at competitive prices. Our core principles of integrity, professionalism, and loyalty guide every client interaction, ensuring comprehensive protection for homes, vehicles, farms, and commercial properties. With over 50 years of local expertise, we specialize in navigating Ohio's unique insurance landscape across Franklin, Delaware, Knox, and 14 additional counties.Our team of trusted advisors focuses on building long-term relationships through transparent communication and customized risk management strategies. Recognized as Ohio Mutual's leading agency and a Grange Insurance Leadership Circle member, we combine industry expertise with community commitment. Our services extend beyond standard policies, addressing specialized needs like collector cars, wine collections, and umbrella liability coverage. We maintain partnerships with premier carriers to deliver innovative solutions for evolving insurance challenges. Client satisfaction remains our top priority, demonstrated through prompt issue resolution and ongoing policyholder education about emerging risks.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Farm Insurance
Business Insurance
Flood Insurance
Commercial Property
General Liability
Umbrella Coverage
Collector Car Insurance
Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1965
Highlights and features
- We offer independent agency access to multiple insurance carriers
- Our team provides 50+ years of Ohio-specific insurance expertise
- We deliver personalized service through seven local office locations
- Our advisors specialize in comprehensive farm and commercial coverage
- We maintain exclusive partnerships with premier insurance providers
Associations and certifications
- Grange Insurance Leadership Circle Agency
- Ohio Mutual Leading Agency
What people say
Helpful
Easy to get ahold of
Great rates
Prompt service
Wonderful service
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance protects against fire, water damage, and personal liability risks. We offer replacement cost coverage with no cap, ensuring adequate protection for rebuilding homes to current codes. Policies include personal property protection and additional living expense coverage during repairs.
Farm Insurance
Specialized farm insurance addresses unique agricultural risks including equipment protection, crop loss, and liability coverage. As Ohio's largest farm writers, we provide tailored solutions for both small family farms and large commercial operations with comprehensive risk management strategies.
Commercial Umbrella
Commercial umbrella policies provide excess liability coverage beyond standard business insurance. This critical protection safeguards company assets against catastrophic claims from lawsuits, offering financial security for businesses across various industries in Ohio.
Collector Car Insurance
Our collector car insurance offers specialized protection for classic and vintage vehicles. Policies include agreed value coverage, spare parts protection, and coverage for shows and parades, recognizing these vehicles' unique value and usage patterns.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance covers property damage from flooding events not included in standard homeowners policies. We offer National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) compliant coverage and private market options to protect homes and businesses in Ohio's changing weather environment.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We provide insurance services throughout Ohio, including Franklin, Delaware, Knox, and 14 other counties with seven local office locations.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We specialize in home, auto, farm, life, and business insurance including specialized coverage for collector cars, commercial properties, and agricultural operations.
How are you different from other agencies?
As Ohio's largest farm writers and a Grange Insurance Leadership Circle Agency, we combine independent multi-carrier access with 50+ years of localized expertise and personalized service.
Can I modify my existing policy?
Yes, you can request policy changes through our client portal or by contacting your dedicated agent directly for personalized adjustments to your coverage.
How do I file a claim?
Contact our office immediately at 740-965-4472 to report claims. Our team will guide you through documentation requirements and coordinate with insurers for prompt resolution.