Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Oxford, OH
Fey Insurance Service has been dedicated to simplifying the complex insurance landscape for clients since our inception. As an independent agency, we prioritize personalized service by leveraging relationships with carefully selected insurance carriers to create tailored protection strategies. Our three-step process begins with understanding client priorities, followed by crafting customized insurance proposals, and culminating in ongoing policy management to adapt to evolving needs. With a heritage spanning four generations of insurance expertise, our team combines deep industry knowledge with a commitment to transparency. We serve as a single point of contact for policyholders, ensuring seamless communication and proactive adjustments to coverage as life circumstances change.

Our Cincinnati-based team maintains strong ties to both local and national insurance markets, enabling competitive rate comparisons without compromising service quality. By focusing exclusively on property, casualty, life, and health insurance lines, we maintain specialized expertise across personal and commercial sectors. Client trust is reinforced through our continuous monitoring of policy performance and industry developments, ensuring long-term alignment with protection goals.
Services
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance Business Insurance Claims Assistance
Highlights and features
  • We offer four generations of insurance expertise and industry knowledge
  • Our team works with top-rated insurance carriers to find best coverage options
  • We provide ongoing policy monitoring and adjustments as needs change
  • Our agents maintain specialized certifications in property, casualty, and life insurance
  • We serve as a single point of contact for all insurance needs
Services
Home Insurance
We provide comprehensive home insurance solutions protecting against property damage, liability claims, and personal belongings coverage. Our policies adapt to changing needs through regular reviews and adjustments. Clients benefit from access to multiple carrier options ensuring competitive pricing and tailored protection levels.
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance services cover personal and commercial vehicles with customizable liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. We help clients navigate state requirements while optimizing protection levels. Policyholders receive ongoing support for claims processing and premium management.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance policies designed to protect families and business interests. Our approach considers long-term financial goals and estate planning needs. Clients receive comparative analyses from multiple carriers to ensure appropriate coverage amounts at competitive rates.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect commercial properties, liability exposures, and operational risks. We specialize in policies for contractors, real estate groups, and nonprofits. Coverage includes property damage, business interruption, and specialized liability protections tailored to industry-specific needs.
Claims Assistance
We provide dedicated claims guidance throughout the entire process. Our team helps document losses, communicate with carriers, and ensure timely resolutions. Policyholders receive personalized support for both personal and commercial insurance claims, maintaining continuity of coverage during claim periods.
People
Brian D. Fey
Owner/Agent
Fourth-generation insurance professional with 20+ years experience. Graduated from Miami University School of Business in 2000. Specializes in commercial insurance and community engagement. Active in local civic organizations.
Holly Bruder
Owner/Agent
Insurance industry veteran since 1995 with teaching background. Holds bachelor's degree from Miami University. Focuses on personal insurance solutions. Active in Oxford community organizations and foundation boards.
Matt Green
Agent
Licensed agent since 2008 with Ohio and Indiana credentials. Specializes in property/casualty and life/health insurance. Holds degree from Nebraska Wesleyan University. Provides cross-border insurance solutions for regional clients.
Brian Goodban
Agent
Risk management specialist with ARM designation. Focuses on commercial real estate and nonprofit organizations. Brings 10+ years commercial insurance experience. Provides strategic coverage solutions for complex business operations.
Elizabeth Mundy
Customer Service Representative
Operations management professional with banking background. Joined agency in 2014. Ensures smooth policy administration and client communication. Maintains focus on personalized service delivery for policyholders.
Questions
How do you tailor insurance policies to individual needs?
We conduct detailed consultations to understand your specific protection requirements before comparing options across our carrier network.
What areas do you serve?
Primarily Oxford and Cincinnati, Ohio, with additional support available for clients across Ohio and Indiana through licensed agents.
How does the claims process work?
We guide clients through documentation requirements and coordinate directly with insurance carriers to expedite claim resolution.
Can you help with business insurance needs?
Yes, we specialize in commercial policies for contractors, real estate groups, and nonprofits with customized risk management solutions.
What insurance carriers do you work with?
We partner with major providers including Auto-Owners, Cincinnati Insurance, Liberty Mutual, Progressive, and Travelers among others.
How often should policies be reviewed?
We recommend annual reviews or whenever significant life changes occur to ensure continued coverage alignment.
Videos