Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
23 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Florida & South Carolina
At St. Johns Insurance, we are committed to providing homeowners, condominium owners, and landlords with reliable insurance solutions tailored to their unique needs. Established in 2003 and headquartered in Orlando, Florida, our mission is to deliver high-quality, financially stable insurance products through a network of experienced agents. We prioritize attentive, personalized service, ensuring our policyholders receive fair pricing and comprehensive coverage for their homes, families, and futures.

Our team of seasoned professionals brings decades of industry expertise, fostering trust and long-term relationships with both agents and policyholders. Rated 'A' Exceptional by Demotech, we uphold rigorous financial stability standards to guarantee prompt claims processing and enduring reliability. By focusing on transparency, responsive claims handling, and a customer-centric approach, we aim to be the insurer our clients can depend on for years to come.
Services
Homeowners Insurance Condo Insurance Landlord Insurance Personal Umbrella Hurricane Coverage
Details
  • Year established: 2003
Highlights and features
  • We offer financially stable insurance products rated 'A' Exceptional by Demotech.
  • Our experienced team provides personalized service tailored to individual needs.
  • We prioritize responsive claims handling and transparent communication.
  • Our exclusive agent network ensures localized expertise and support.
  • We combine decades of industry experience with a commitment to long-term reliability.
Associations and certifications
  • Demotech 'A' Exceptional
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance protects your dwelling, personal property, and liability risks. Coverage includes damage from perils like fire, theft, and natural disasters, along with loss of use and personal liability protection. Designed for Florida and South Carolina residents, this policy ensures financial security for your largest investment through competitive pricing and responsive claims handling.
Condo Insurance
Condo insurance safeguards your unit's interior, personal belongings, and liability exposures. Tailored for condominium owners, it complements the master policy by covering interior structures, fixtures, and personal liability. Our policies address unique risks faced by condo dwellers, ensuring comprehensive protection for both property and assets in Florida and South Carolina.
Landlord Insurance
Landlord insurance protects investment properties against property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. This policy covers structural damage, personal liability, and additional expenses from covered events. Designed for property owners in Florida and South Carolina, it provides financial security against risks associated with rental properties, including tenant-related incidents.
Personal Umbrella
Personal umbrella insurance offers excess liability coverage beyond standard homeowners or auto policies. It protects against catastrophic claims that exceed primary policy limits, safeguarding assets from lawsuits or severe accidents. Available in Florida and South Carolina, this policy provides an extra layer of security for individuals seeking enhanced liability protection.
Hurricane Coverage
Hurricane coverage addresses property damage from hurricanes and tropical storms, including wind, flooding, and debris-related losses. Integrated into homeowners or landlord policies, it ensures financial protection for Florida and South Carolina residents in high-risk areas. Our policies emphasize preparedness and swift claims resolution to minimize disruptions after storm events.
People
Jesse Schalk
President
Jesse Schalk brings over 30 years of insurance and financial management experience. Prior roles include Vice President of Finance at American Management Corporation and General Manager at Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Company. He holds a BS in Accounting from Arkansas Tech University and is a licensed CPA (inactive) in Arkansas.
Russell Beck
Executive Vice President
Russell Beck has 15 years of homeowners insurance claims management experience. He previously served as Regional Claims Manager for Zurich Risk Management Services and holds certifications as a Florida State Certified Residential Contractor and Senior Claims Law Associate. He graduated from Florida State University.
Questions
What types of insurance does St. Johns Insurance Company offer?
St. Johns offers homeowners, condo, landlord, and personal umbrella insurance policies in Florida and South Carolina.
How can I file a claim with St. Johns Insurance?
File a claim by contacting our toll-free number (877-748-2059) or using our online platform for prompt assistance.
Is St. Johns Insurance financially stable?
Yes, we are rated 'A' Exceptional by Demotech, reflecting our strong financial health and reliability.
Do you offer discounts for bundling policies?
While not explicitly stated, our agents can help explore cost-saving options for combined coverage needs.