Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in St. Marys, PA
Straub Insurance Agency has been serving clients since 1959, providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. As an independent agency representing Erie Insurance, we combine over 60 years of local expertise with access to a trusted national carrier. Our team of experienced professionals prioritizes personalized service, competitive pricing, and a broad range of insurance products to protect homes, vehicles, businesses, and families.We are committed to building long-term relationships through transparency, prompt service, and a deep understanding of our clients' unique risk management requirements. With offices in St. Marys and Emporium, Pennsylvania, we offer 24/7 online client services while maintaining the personal touch of face-to-face consultations. Our dedication to excellence has earned us the trust of generations of policyholders who value our proactive approach to insurance coverage.
Services
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
RV Insurance
Boat Insurance
Workers Compensation
Medicare Supplements
Annuity/IRA
Details
- Year established: 1959
Highlights and features
- We offer over 60 years of combined insurance expertise in Pennsylvania markets
- Our team provides personalized coverage recommendations tailored to individual needs
- 24/7 online client services for payments, claims, and policy management
- We represent Erie Insurance, a nationally recognized carrier with local service
- Experienced staff specializes in both personal and commercial insurance solutions
What people say
Great follow-up service
Upfront and honest
Prompt service
Knowledgeable staff
Personalized attention
Services
Auto Insurance
Protect your vehicle investment with comprehensive auto insurance policies tailored to your driving habits and budget. Our coverage options include liability protection, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist protection while offering discounts for safe drivers and multi-policy bundling. With 24/7 claims support and competitive pricing through Erie Insurance, we help Pennsylvania drivers maintain compliance and financial security.
Business Insurance
Safeguard your business operations with customized commercial insurance packages that address industry-specific risks. We offer general liability coverage, business interruption insurance, and commercial auto policies that protect your physical assets, legal liabilities, and operational continuity. Our experts work closely with Pennsylvania businesses to create comprehensive risk management strategies that adapt to evolving needs.
Homeowners Insurance
Secure your most valuable asset with homeowners insurance that protects against property damage, personal liability claims, and additional living expenses. Our policies include dwelling coverage, personal property protection, and flood insurance options that meet Pennsylvania's unique climate challenges. We help homeowners understand policy details and select appropriate coverage limits for their specific properties.
Life Insurance
Ensure your family's financial future with term, whole, and universal life insurance policies that provide death benefits and cash value accumulation. We offer flexible premium options and policy structures that accommodate different life stages and financial goals. Our agents explain policy features like riders, conversion options, and tax advantages to help clients make informed decisions.
Health Insurance
Access comprehensive health insurance solutions for individuals under 65 and seniors transitioning to Medicare. We provide guidance on selecting appropriate deductible levels, network coverage, and supplemental policies like Medicare Part D and Advantage plans. Our support includes explaining policy benefits, prescription coverage, and enrollment periods to ensure adequate medical protection.
People
Stephen M. Straub
Agent
Stephen brings decades of insurance expertise to personal and commercial policyholders, specializing in comprehensive risk management solutions. He maintains direct client relationships while overseeing agency operations.
Leo Simbeck
Agent
Leo specializes in both personal and commercial insurance products, leveraging extensive industry experience to develop tailored coverage strategies for Pennsylvania residents and businesses.
Staci Enyedy
Agent
Staci provides expert insurance guidance for individuals and businesses, focusing on life, health, and property coverage options that balance protection with affordability.
Jon Songer
Customer Service Rep
Jon supports policyholders with day-to-day insurance needs, handling policy changes, claims processing, and coverage inquiries with prompt, personalized attention.
Sue Schlimm
Commercial Lines Specialist
Sue focuses on commercial insurance solutions, assisting business owners with complex coverage requirements and risk assessment strategies tailored to their specific industries.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, life, and health insurance including specialized coverage for RVs, boats, classic cars, and commercial operations through Erie Insurance.
Are you available outside regular business hours?
Our offices operate Monday-Friday 8:30 AM-5:30 PM but offer 24/7 online services for payments, claims filing, and policy management.
How can I get a quick insurance quote?
Request instant quotes through our website or contact our St. Marys office at (814) 834-2490 for personalized coverage recommendations.
Do you serve both individuals and businesses?
Yes, we specialize in both personal insurance for families and comprehensive commercial coverage for businesses of all sizes.
What makes your agency different?
We combine local expertise with national carrier strength, offering personalized service from experienced agents who understand Pennsylvania's unique insurance needs.
How do I file a claim?
Submit claims online 24/7 through the Erie Insurance portal or contact our office directly for immediate assistance with the claims process.
