Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
We are Gaines Insurance Agency, a trusted independent insurance provider serving Vermonts Champlain Valley since our founding in 1961 by Allen W. Gaines. For more than six decades, we have built a reputation for reliable, personalized service rooted in deep local knowledge of the communities we serve. Our team holds multiple specialized insurance designations, including Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC), Accredited Adviser in Insurance (AAI), Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR), and Construction Risk Insurance Specialist (CRIS) credentials. We leverage this combined expertise to carefully analyze each clients unique risk profile and coverage needs. We represent a curated selection of highly rated insurance carriers, including long-standing partner Co-operative Insurance Companies, to deliver tailored, cost-effective policy options. Our problem-solving capabilities allow us to navigate complex coverage requirements for auto, home, farm, and small business policyholders across Addison and southern Chittenden Counties.

We uphold the highest professional standards, staying current with industry changes through ongoing continuing education for our entire team. We prioritize full transparency in all client interactions, clearly explaining policy terms, available discounts, and coverage details so clients can make informed decisions. Our commitment to client satisfaction extends beyond policy sales, including flexible payment plans, dedicated claims support, and even in-person house calls for existing customers. We have maintained Allen Gaines original tradition of putting client needs first for over 60 years, earning the trust of thousands of Vermont families and business owners. We take pride in our long-standing track record of responsive, community-focused service that sets us apart from larger, impersonal insurance providers.
Highlights and features
  • We have served Vermonts Champlain Valley since 1961.
  • Our team holds 4 specialized insurance professional designations.
  • We provide in-person house calls for existing customers.
  • We represent top-rated carriers including Co-operative Insurance Companies.
  • We offer auto policy discounts exceeding 50% with select carriers.
Services
Auto Insurance
We offer comprehensive auto insurance policies for personal passenger vehicles across Vermont. Our coverage options include liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protection tailored to individual driver needs. Policyholders can access significant discounts for good driving records, good credit, good students, and vehicle safety features, with some clients saving over 50% on premiums.
Home Insurance
We provide customizable homeowners insurance policies to protect Vermont residential properties and personal belongings. Coverage options include dwelling protection, personal property coverage, liability protection, and additional living expenses for displaced homeowners. Clients can qualify for discounts for good loss history, smoke alarms, fire extinguishers, and newer home construction.
Farm Insurance
We specialize in tailored farm insurance policies for agricultural operations across Vermonts Champlain Valley. Our coverage protects farm property, livestock, equipment, and farm liability risks for small and large-scale agricultural businesses. As a long-standing farm insurance provider since 1961, we understand the unique risks faced by Vermont farmers and customize coverage to match their specific operational needs.
Small Business Insurance
We offer comprehensive small business insurance policies for local companies across Addison and southern Chittenden Counties. Our coverage options include general liability, property insurance, workers compensation, and business interruption protection to mitigate operational risks. We work closely with business owners to assess their unique exposure and build cost-effective coverage packages that align with their budget and operational needs.