Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Newaygo, MI
Newaygo Insurance has served Michigan communities for over five decades, providing tailored insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. Our locally rooted team combines deep industry knowledge with personalized service, ensuring clients receive coverage that aligns with their unique needs. With expertise in auto, home, commercial, farm, health, life, and specialty insurance, we prioritize client education and proactive risk management.Our commitment to community extends beyond policies, as evidenced by our flexible service approach and active involvement in local initiatives. Backed by partnerships with major insurers and a focus on innovation, we deliver reliable protection while maintaining the trust of generations of clients.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Farm Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Pet Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer over 50 years of localized insurance expertise tailored to Michigan residents.
- Our team provides personalized coverage reviews and 24-hour claim reporting.
- We represent eight major auto insurance carriers for competitive pricing options.
- Farm insurance specialists with generational agricultural experience serve rural clients.
- Our commercial insurance team offers risk management beyond standard policy sales.
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect Michigan drivers with customizable coverage options. We partner with eight major insurers to offer competitive rates for personal and commercial vehicles. Clients benefit from 24-hour claim reporting and flexible payment plans while receiving tailored protection that meets state requirements and individual needs.
Farm Insurance
Specialized farm insurance solutions address Michigan's agricultural risks including crop loss, equipment damage, and liability concerns. Our agents combine generational farming experience with industry expertise to ensure proper coverage for livestock, machinery, and property. Policies adapt to evolving farm operations while maintaining cost-effective protection.
Commercial Insurance
We provide comprehensive commercial insurance for Michigan businesses across multiple sectors including manufacturing, retail, and professional services. Our risk management approach goes beyond policy sales by offering tailored liability protection, property coverage, and industry-specific solutions that address evolving business challenges.
Home Insurance
Homeowners insurance policies protect Michigan properties with coverage for structures, personal belongings, and liability risks. We offer replacement cost options and specialized coverage for high-value items while representing nine major insurers to ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive protection.
Health Insurance
Our health insurance services help Michigan residents and businesses select appropriate coverage from multiple providers. We assist with individual and group plans that balance premium costs with deductible requirements while offering guidance on Medicare options and supplemental coverage solutions.
People
Dan Johnson
Agency Owner
Dan Johnson leads Newaygo Insurance with over 15 years of leadership experience. Holding dual insurance licenses, he specializes in farm insurance while managing a local beef farm operation.
Marcy Johnson
Agency Owner
Marcy Johnson contributes business administration expertise and property insurance knowledge. As co-owner since 2009, she focuses on client relationships while maintaining industry licensing standards.
Ryan Seyferth
General Manager
Ryan Seyferth oversees daily operations with agricultural insurance expertise. His construction industry background informs risk assessment approaches while managing the agency's farm/commercial department since 2017.
Grace Larson
Group Benefits Coordinator
Grace Larson manages employee benefits programs with property, casualty, and health insurance licenses. She transitioned from farm insurance sales to specialize in corporate benefits solutions since 2020.
Teresa Steenhagen
Farm Service Agent
Teresa Steenhagen provides farm insurance expertise with over 20 years of industry experience. Holding the CISR designation, she serves agricultural clients from the Sparta office location.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, commercial, farm, life, health, Medicare, and pet insurance for Michigan residents and businesses.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request quotes through our website contact form, by phone at 231-652-1636, or visit our Newaygo office for personalized assistance.
Do you offer 24-hour claim reporting?
Yes, our auto insurance clients receive 24-hour claim reporting access for emergency situations.
Are you a local insurance agency?
Yes, we've served Newaygo County and surrounding Michigan communities for over 50 years with locally tailored insurance solutions.
Can I purchase multiple insurance policies?
Yes, we offer bundled coverage options for home, auto, and commercial insurance to provide cost savings.
