Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Hartville, OH
Founded in 1957, Yoder-Bontrager Insurance has built a legacy of providing personalized, community-focused insurance solutions. As an independent agency, we partner with multiple carriers to offer tailored home, auto, life, business, church, and farm insurance policies that meet the unique needs of individuals, families, and organizations. Our commitment to listening first ensures clients receive coverage that aligns with their values and financial goals. With over 50 years of experience and deep roots in the Hartville community, we prioritize faith-driven service, transparency, and long-term relationships.Our team of certified agents combines specialized expertise with a hometown touch, offering 24/7 support and advocacy during claims processes. We specialize in protecting diverse businesses, including contractors, medical providers, retailers, and farms, while maintaining a steadfast dedication to ethical practices and client education.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Church Insurance
Farm Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1957
Highlights and features
- We offer 65+ years of independent insurance expertise since 1957
- Our team provides personalized service with community-based understanding
- We partner with multiple carriers to find optimal coverage options
- Faith-driven approach integrates ethical values with financial protection
- Specialized commercial insurance for contractors, medical providers, and farms
What people say
Top notch customer service
Friendly hometown atmosphere
Saved us money through bundling
Responsive during claims process
Understand local insurance needs
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your primary residence, seasonal home, or rental property with customizable policies. We offer flood, sewer backup, and identity theft coverage options. Our independent agency helps clients in Hartville and surrounding areas secure comprehensive protection that adapts to evolving risks while maintaining affordability through strategic carrier partnerships.
Business Insurance
Tailored insurance solutions for contractors, medical providers, retailers, and manufacturers. Coverage includes liability protection, property damage, and business interruption. Our agents specialize in creating risk management strategies that address industry-specific challenges while ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements through trusted carriers like Erie Insurance.
Church Insurance
Comprehensive protection for religious organizations through our Ministry Assistance Program. Policies cover property damage, liability, and operational risks for churches, schools, and faith-based daycares. Our faith-driven approach ensures alignment with organizational values while providing financial security against unforeseen events that could disrupt community services.
Farm Insurance
Customized insurance for family farms and agricultural businesses. Protection includes crop loss, livestock mortality, equipment breakdown, and liability coverage. We specialize in policies for dairy farms, hobby farms, and farm-based businesses, ensuring compliance with evolving agricultural regulations while safeguarding rural livelihoods in Northeast Ohio.
Life Insurance
Term and permanent life insurance policies designed to protect families and businesses. Term options provide affordable coverage for specific periods, while permanent policies build cash value. Our agents help clients understand policy nuances, ensuring adequate protection for dependents and business continuity in case of unexpected loss.
People
Emily Bontrager-Manchester
Personal Lines Agent
Specializing in auto, home, and umbrella insurance, Emily provides personalized coverage solutions with a focus on client education and risk assessment.
Chris Minick
Personal Lines Agent
Certified property and casualty expert helping clients protect their assets through strategic insurance planning and comprehensive policy analysis.
Paul Bontrager
Principal Agent
Leading commercial insurance solutions with decades of experience in risk management for contractors and business owners across Northeast Ohio.
Joey Viscounte
Commercial Account Manager
Specializes in balancing personal lines expertise with commercial risk assessment to create holistic insurance strategies for business clients.
Jody Miller
Customer Service Representative
Provides friendly support and policy assistance, ensuring seamless client experiences from initial consultation to claims resolution.
Questions
What types of insurance do you specialize in?
We offer home, auto, life, business, church, and farm insurance with specialized coverage options for unique needs.
Are you locally owned and operated?
Yes, we've served Hartville and surrounding communities since 1957 with personalized insurance solutions.
How can I save on insurance premiums?
Bundle policies, maintain good credit, and qualify for multi-vehicle discounts to reduce insurance costs.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
While not available 24/7, we prioritize prompt claims assistance during regular business hours with emergency guidance.
Can you insure unique properties like hobby farms?
Yes, we create customized farm insurance policies for hobby farms, horse farms, and agricultural businesses of all sizes.
How does your independent agency benefit me?
We compare multiple carriers to find competitive rates and tailored coverage options that match your specific needs.
