Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Madill, OK
Butler Insurance Agency has been family-owned and operated since 1916, making us the oldest independent insurance agency in Oklahoma. Our team brings over 75 years of combined experience in home, auto, and commercial insurance, serving clients across Southern Oklahoma and Northern Texas. We prioritize personalized service, offering free quotes and same-day appointments while maintaining partnerships with major insurers like Liberty Mutual and Progressive.Our commitment to continuing education ensures we provide up-to-date, tailored coverage solutions. With three local offices in Madill, Kingston, and Tishomingo, we combine century-old trust with modern insurance expertise to protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Flood Insurance
Health Insurance
Renters Insurance
Event Insurance
Business Auto Insurance
Workers' Compensation
Bond Services
Details
- Year established: 1916
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1916 with deep local insurance expertise
- Over 75 years of combined experience in home, auto, and commercial coverage
- Competitive rates through partnerships with major insurers like Liberty Mutual
- Same-day appointments and free, no-obligation quotes available
- Continuing education ensures up-to-date insurance knowledge and service standards
Associations and certifications
- Big I - Oklahoma Independent Insurance Agency Association
What people say
Excellent customer service
Knowledgeable, professional
Exceptional support
Helpful for all needs
No one to beat pricewise
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Protect your home against fire, flood, and other disasters with customizable policies. We offer competitive rates and personalized consultations to ensure your property and belongings remain secure. Our team works with top-rated insurers to provide comprehensive protection tailored to Oklahoma's unique risks.
Auto Insurance
Get reliable auto insurance for cars, trucks, and motorcycles with flexible coverage options. We partner with major providers like All-State to offer competitive rates while helping clients understand policy details. Same-day appointments available for immediate coverage needs.
Commercial Insurance
Safeguard your business with liability, property, and workers' compensation insurance. Our specialized policies cover general liability, commercial auto, and inland marine risks. We help Oklahoma businesses manage risks through tailored solutions and partnerships with leading commercial insurers.
Health Insurance
Access individual and group health insurance plans with options for different needs. We provide consultations to help clients understand policy terms and select appropriate coverage. Our partnerships with major providers ensure competitive rates for personal and business health insurance solutions.
Flood Insurance
Secure specialized flood coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program. We help homeowners and businesses in high-risk areas obtain protection against water damage. Our team explains policy details and ensures proper coverage limits for Oklahoma's flood-prone regions.
Questions
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Call us at (580) 795-3315 or visit our Madill, Kingston, or Tishomingo offices for same-day quotes. We provide no-obligation consultations to help you understand coverage options.
What insurance services do you offer?
We provide homeowners, auto, commercial, flood, health, renters, event, business auto, bonds, and workers' compensation insurance for clients across Southern Oklahoma and Northern Texas.
How long has Butler Insurance been in business?
We've been family-owned and operated since 1916, making us Oklahoma's oldest independent insurance agency with over 100 years of continuous service.
Do you accept multiple payment methods?
Yes, we accept cash, checks, American Express, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa for insurance premiums and related services.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Madill, Kingston, Tishomingo, and surrounding areas in Southern Oklahoma and Northern Texas with in-person appointments at our three local offices.
Can I get same-day insurance service?
Yes, we offer same-day appointments for most services. Contact our team to discuss urgent coverage needs and receive immediate assistance.
