Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in South Jersey
Founded in 1922, McMahon Agency has built a legacy of excellence in meeting insurance needs across New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Delaware. With four strategically located offices in Ocean City, Manahawkin, Marmora, and Cape May, we serve clients through a team of 64 dedicated professionals. Our agency prides itself on personalized service, avoiding generic call centers by offering direct access to our team 24/7/365. As an independent agency, we partner with over 35 top-rated insurers to secure competitive pricing while maintaining deep expertise in specialized areas like flood insurance, where we were recognized as National Flood Insurance Program Agent of the Year.Our commitment extends beyond transactionswe maintain relationships with local contractors and lenders to resolve insurance concerns swiftly. Over nearly a century, we've evolved from a single office to a regional leader while preserving our core values of integrity, responsiveness, and community stewardship.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Flood Insurance
Condominium Insurance
Business Insurance
Personal Auto Insurance
Marine Insurance
Group Health Insurance
Life Insurance
Umbrella Liability Insurance
Coastal Property Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1922
Highlights and features
- We offer 24/7 personalized customer support with direct access to our team
- Our agency specializes in flood insurance with national recognition
- We leverage independence to shop coverage across 35+ top-rated insurers
- We maintain local relationships to resolve insurance concerns swiftly
- Our century-long legacy demonstrates proven industry expertise
Associations and certifications
- National Flood Insurance Program
What people say
Outstanding service
Open communication
Knowledgeable staff
Quick resolution
Family approach
Services
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect commercial properties, liability risks, and operational continuity. We specialize in customized policies for coastal businesses, offering coverage for property damage, liability claims, and business interruption. Our team works with clients to assess risk exposure and secure policies that meet specific industry requirements.
Flood Insurance
We provide specialized flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program and private carriers. Our expertise includes coastal property coverage, flood zone assessments, and policy customization for high-risk areas. We assist clients with claims documentation and mitigation strategies to protect against water-related damages.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect against property damage, liability claims, and personal belongings loss. We offer standard and enhanced coverage options for primary residences, vacation homes, and rental properties across multiple states with tailored risk management solutions.
Condominium Insurance
We specialize in condominium insurance that covers interior structures, personal property, and liability beyond master policy coverage. Our team helps owners understand HOA policy gaps and secure appropriate loss assessments and additional living expense coverage.
Marine Insurance
Our marine insurance covers recreational and commercial vessels, including damage from collisions, weather events, and theft. Policies include liability protection, wreck removal, and coverage for personal watercraft with specialized options for coastal and inland waterway operations.
People
Bill McMahon III
President
Third-generation leader with deep insurance expertise, Bill oversees agency operations while maintaining client relationships. He continues the family legacy of personalized service established in 1922 through strategic growth and community engagement.
Maura McMahon Primus
Vice President
As Vice President, Maura manages key operational functions while ensuring service quality across all departments. Her leadership focuses on maintaining the agency's core values while implementing modern insurance solutions for evolving client needs.
Michael P. McMahon
Claims Manager
Michael leads our claims team with a focus on rapid resolution and client advocacy. He provides direct support for complex claims, particularly post-disaster situations, ensuring policyholders receive timely and fair settlements.
Patrick McMahon
Commercial Lines Manager
Patrick specializes in commercial risk management, developing tailored insurance solutions for businesses. His expertise includes property, liability, and specialized industry coverage to protect diverse commercial operations across multiple states.
Brian McMahon
Chief Operations Officer
Brian oversees daily operations and technological infrastructure, ensuring efficient service delivery. He focuses on maintaining the agency's century-old commitment to personalized service while implementing modern systems for client convenience.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide homeowners, flood, condominium, business, marine, auto, life, and group health insurance. Our specialized coverage includes coastal property protection and umbrella liability policies.
Do you serve areas outside New Jersey?
Yes, we write policies for clients in Pennsylvania and Delaware, maintaining tri-state convenience through our four New Jersey locations.
How do you handle insurance claims?
Our team immediately notifies carriers and guides clients through resolution. For urgent matters, our claims manager provides direct assistance 24/7 via phone or email.
Can you help compare insurance options?
As an independent agency, we compare coverage from 35+ insurers to find optimal value while explaining policy details and coverage differences.
What payment options are available?
Clients can pay online through carrier portals or contact our office directly for payment assistance. Specific payment methods vary by insurance provider.
How are you prepared for natural disasters?
With decades of coastal experience, we maintain emergency response protocols and local contractor relationships to expedite post-disaster claims, particularly for flood-related incidents.
Videos
