Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Buford, GA
Sutter McLellan & Gilbreath has been a trusted independent insurance agency since 1953, dedicated to creating strategic partnerships between clients, carriers, and the community. Our mission focuses on delivering tailored insurance solutions through clear communication and concise program design. We prioritize asset protection, cost efficiency, and transparent pricing to meet client expectations. With expertise in commercial, personal, life, and health insurance, we serve businesses and families across Metro Atlanta and Georgia. Our commitment extends to claims management, loss control, and insurance negotiations, ensuring clients avoid costly surprises.

As part of Alera Group since 2022, we combine local insight with national resources to enhance client programs. Our team of licensed professionals specializes in risk management, offering personalized service backed by decades of experience. We emphasize simplified pricing structures and proactive communication to align insurance strategies with client goals. Our long-standing reputation reflects a dedication to ethical practices, client education, and innovative insurance solutions tailored to evolving needs.
Services
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance Commercial Insurance Builders Risk Insurance Health Insurance Workers Compensation General Liability Bond Services Medicare Coverage
Details
  • Year established: 1953
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 70 years of experience in insurance services across Georgia.
  • Our team provides tailored risk management solutions for businesses and families.
  • We combine coverages into streamlined programs to eliminate redundant costs.
  • Our transparent pricing ensures clients anticipate and allocate insurance costs accurately.
  • Affiliation with Alera Group enhances our ability to deliver comprehensive insurance strategies.
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance provides financial protection against vehicle-related risks, including accidents, theft, and liability claims. Our policies cater to personal and commercial needs, offering customizable coverage options. Clients benefit from competitive rates and expert guidance to ensure compliance and asset protection.
Commercial Insurance
Commercial insurance safeguards businesses against risks like property damage, liability, and operational disruptions. We design tailored programs for diverse industries, combining property, liability, and specialized coverages. Our approach ensures cost efficiency and comprehensive risk management for long-term stability.
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners insurance protects against damage to property and belongings, along with liability coverage for accidents on the premises. We offer policies tailored to individual needs, ensuring affordability and security. Clients receive personalized support to navigate claims and policy adjustments.
Builders Risk Insurance
Builders risk insurance covers property damage during construction or renovation projects. Our solutions protect against perils like fire, theft, and weather-related incidents. Clients gain peace of mind with coverage that adapts to project-specific risks and timelines.
Life Insurance
Life insurance provides financial security for beneficiaries upon the policyholder's death. We offer term and permanent policies tailored to individual goals, such as income replacement or estate planning. Clients receive expert advice to select coverage that aligns with their long-term needs.
People
Drew Gilbreath
Managing Partner
Drew Gilbreath leads Sutter McLellan & Gilbreath with expertise in commercial insurance and risk management. He oversees strategic growth and client relationships, ensuring alignment with the agency's mission.
Judy Shaw
Senior Partner
Judy Shaw brings decades of insurance experience to her role, focusing on client service and program development. She specializes in commercial lines and contributes to the agency's long-term success.
Chris Taylor
Account Executive
Chris Taylor specializes in commercial insurance solutions, helping businesses mitigate risks and secure comprehensive coverage. His client-centric approach ensures tailored strategies for diverse industries.
Becky Nigh
Commercial Lines Manager
Becky Nigh manages commercial insurance operations, leveraging her expertise in risk assessment and policy design. She ensures clients receive efficient, cost-effective coverage tailored to their needs.
James Sullivan
Claims Manager
James Sullivan oversees claims processing, advocating for clients to ensure timely and fair resolutions. His experience in insurance claims management enhances client trust and satisfaction.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, commercial, builders risk, health, and workers compensation insurance, along with bond services and Medicare coverage.
How can you help reduce insurance costs?
We combine coverages into streamlined programs to eliminate redundancies and offer competitive pricing tailored to your specific risk profile.
Do you serve businesses outside Metro Atlanta?
Yes, we serve clients throughout Georgia, providing customized insurance solutions for businesses and individuals statewide.
What is builders risk insurance?
Builders risk insurance covers property damage during construction or renovation projects, protecting against perils like fire, theft, and weather-related incidents.
Are you affiliated with any national organizations?
We are part of Alera Group, a national insurance and wealth services firm, enhancing our ability to deliver comprehensive solutions.