Business Details
15 Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Services in Naples & Marco Island, FL
Forsythe Insurance Services has been a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions since 2011, serving individuals, families, and businesses in Naples, Marco Island, and surrounding areas. Founded on principles of personalized service and local expertise, our agency is led by Rob Forsythe, who brings 28 years of industry experience and deep community knowledge to every client interaction. As a Trusted Choice agency, we specialize in homeowners, auto, condo, and commercial insurance, offering tailored policies and monthly payment plans to meet diverse needs.Our commitment extends beyond policy saleswe advocate for clients during claims and prioritize transparent, ethical service. With a focus on understanding regional risks, including hurricane preparedness, we deliver coverage that protects what matters most while adapting to evolving client requirements.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Condo Insurance
Flood Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Boat Insurance
RV Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2011
Highlights and features
- We offer 28 years of local insurance expertise tailored to Southwest Florida's unique needs
- Our agency provides personalized policy comparisons and monthly payment flexibility
- We advocate for clients during insurance claims with dedicated local support
- Specialized hurricane preparedness coverage options for coastal property protection
- Trusted Choice agency status reflects our commitment to ethical insurance practices
Associations and certifications
- Trusted Choice
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance protects your primary residence against common perils like fire, theft, and storm damage while offering optional flood coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program. We provide replacement cost policies and inflation guard clauses to maintain adequate protection as construction costs change. Our agents help clients understand policy limits for personal possessions and liability coverage that protects against property damage claims.
Auto Insurance
We offer mandatory liability coverage and comprehensive auto policies that meet Florida's legal requirements while protecting against collision and non-collision related damages. Our services include motorcycle and RV insurance options with specialized coverage for recreational vehicles. Knowledgeable agents help clients balance premium costs with adequate protection levels while explaining deductible options and claims processes.
Condo Insurance
Our condo insurance policies protect unit owners' personal property and interior structures while coordinating with master association policies. We offer monthly payment plans and help clients understand coverage for special features, building materials, and local code compliance requirements. Policies address unique risks like hurricane damage and water intrusion while maintaining affordability for Florida residents.
Flood Insurance
We provide flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program to protect properties in high-risk areas. Our agents explain policy details about building code compliance costs and elevation requirements while helping clients understand coverage limitations for pre-FIRM construction. We offer policy comparisons to ensure adequate protection for coastal properties vulnerable to storm surges and heavy rainfall events.
Umbrella Insurance
Our umbrella insurance policies provide excess liability protection beyond standard homeowners and auto policies. We help clients understand coverage for lawsuits, property damage claims, and personal injury incidents that exceed primary policy limits. Policies protect against catastrophic losses while offering peace of mind for individuals with significant assets or higher risk exposure.
People
Rob Forsythe
Owner
Rob Forsythe brings 28 years of insurance expertise to Southwest Florida residents, having lived in Naples since 1975. His local knowledge informs personalized policy recommendations that address regional risks while maintaining affordability. He advocates for clients during claims processes and prioritizes transparent communication about coverage options and policy limitations.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide homeowners, auto, condo, flood, umbrella, boat, RV, motorcycle, and commercial insurance policies tailored to Southwest Florida's unique needs.
Do you offer payment plans?
Yes, we offer monthly payment plans for most insurance products to help clients manage premium costs while maintaining continuous coverage.
Are you a local agency?
Yes, we're based in Marco Island and have served Naples and surrounding areas since 2011 with deep understanding of regional insurance requirements.
How do you help with claims?
We advocate for clients during the claims process, providing guidance and support to ensure fair treatment while explaining policy coverage details.
What makes you different from other agencies?
Our 28 years of local experience combined with Trusted Choice agency status ensures personalized service focused on Southwest Florida's specific insurance challenges.
Do you offer hurricane preparedness coverage?
Yes, we provide extended replacement cost policies and ordinance or law endorsements to address post-storm rebuilding cost increases and code compliance requirements.
