Business Details
48 Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Tallahassee Since 1978
Since 1978, we have been committed to providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to the unique needs of individuals and businesses. As an independent agency representing over 100 carriers, we prioritize client choice and personalized service. Our legacy of trust is built on decades-long relationships with clients and team members, including multiple generations of families we've served. We take pride in our industry expertise, demonstrated through professional designations like CPCU, ARM, and LUTCF, and our active involvement in the Tallahassee community. Our transition to independence in 2009 expanded our ability to offer competitive policies while maintaining the integrity and service excellence established by founder Doug Croley.Our team combines deep technical knowledge with local market insights to deliver customized risk management strategies. We maintain strong partnerships with leading insurers including Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, and Travelers, ensuring access to innovative coverage options. Our agency's longevity and repeat client base reflect our commitment to transparency, ethical practices, and continuous adaptation to evolving insurance needs.
Services
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Group Health Insurance
Specialty Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1978
Highlights and features
- We offer 40+ years of insurance expertise with multiple carrier partnerships
- Our team holds professional designations including CPCU and ARM
- We provide personalized service with local Tallahassee market knowledge
- Our agency maintains multi-generational client relationships
- We combine national carrier access with independent agency flexibility
Services
Personal Insurance
We provide comprehensive personal insurance solutions including home, auto, and specialty coverage for valuable items. Our policies protect clients' assets while offering flexible options through multiple carrier partnerships. With tailored umbrella policies and special event insurance, we address unique risk management needs for Florida residents.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance services cover property, liability, and specialized business risks including cyber threats and professional liability. We help Florida businesses develop comprehensive risk management strategies with coverage options from top-rated carriers. Our expertise includes directors & officers liability and excess liability protection.
Life Insurance
We offer diverse life insurance products including term, whole life, and specialty policies for family protection and estate planning. Our services include key man life insurance for businesses and buy/sell agreements. With access to multiple carriers, we help clients find appropriate coverage for their financial security needs.
Group Health Insurance
Our group health insurance solutions help businesses provide competitive benefits packages to employees. We work with multiple carriers to find cost-effective health coverage options that meet employers' budgetary requirements while maintaining quality care access for employees and their families.
Specialty Insurance
We specialize in unique insurance solutions including MedJet membership for emergency air transport and specialty property coverage for high-value items. Our expertise extends to specialty insurance needs like wedding events and landlord property protection across the Tallahassee area.
People
Mary Katharine (Croley) Lawler
President
President with Master of Science in Risk Management from Florida State University. Holds Associate in Risk Management designation. Former insurance broker at Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. and adjunct professor at FSU. Active in Florida Association of Insurance Agents and Tallahassee community organizations.
John William Will Croley
Vice President
Vice President and Flagler University graduate with military service in Iraq. Active in Tallahassee business community leadership roles including Network of Entrepreneurs and Honor Flight Network. Participates in Florida Future Insurance Leaders program.
Angela Hearl
Senior Vice President
Senior Vice President with 30+ years agency experience. Florida State University graduate who has taught insurance licensing courses. Active community member with leadership roles in business associations and Havana Golf Club.
Douglas M. Croley
Founder
Founder with advanced degrees from University of Florida and Florida State University. Holds CPCU and LUTCF designations. Former Presidents Club award winner with Nationwide Insurance. Transitioned agency to independence in 2009 while maintaining community leadership roles.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (home, auto, life), commercial insurance (business property, liability), and specialty coverage including MedJet membership and special event insurance.
Are you an independent insurance agency?
Yes, we represent over 100 insurance carriers including Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, and Travelers to provide clients with multiple coverage options.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Contact us via phone at (850) 386-1922 or through our website to receive a free, personalized insurance quote from multiple carriers.
Do you serve businesses in Tallahassee?
Yes, we offer commercial insurance solutions for Tallahassee businesses including property, liability, and cyber insurance coverage options.
What makes your agency different?
With 40+ years local experience and multiple carrier partnerships, we combine personalized service with access to competitive insurance products tailored to Florida's unique needs.
Can I meet with an agent in person?
Yes, our Tallahassee office at 2814 Remington Green Circle offers in-person appointments Monday-Friday during regular business hours.
