Business Details
19 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Fort Myers, FL
Bacarella Insurance Group has been serving Southwest Florida since 2007, providing comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions. With over 25 years of combined experience in property and casualty insurance, our team specializes in tailoring coverage to meet individual and business needs while prioritizing client education and cost-effectiveness. We maintain partnerships with major insurance carriers to offer competitive options, emphasizing transparency and integrity in every policy.Our family-owned agency combines local market expertise with a commitment to community service, supporting local churches, youth programs, and food donation initiatives. We focus on proactive risk management, helping clients identify coverage gaps and avoid overlaps that could jeopardize their financial security.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Commercial Liability
Flood Insurance
RV Insurance
Life Insurance
Workers Compensation
Condo Insurance
Health Insurance
Long Term Care
Details
- Year established: 2007
Highlights and features
- We offer 25+ years of property & casualty insurance expertise
- Our team provides personalized policy recommendations based on individual needs
- We maintain partnerships with all major personal insurance markets
- Our family-owned agency prioritizes community involvement and local knowledge
- We specialize in identifying coverage gaps and eliminating policy overlaps
What people say
Kind and thoughtful service
Genuine help with insurance needs
Community-focused approach
Effective coverage solutions
Dedicated client support
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance policies protect against property damage, liability claims, and additional living expenses. We help clients understand policy details including dwelling coverage, personal property protection, and liability limits. Our team ensures proper valuation of homes to prevent underinsurance while maintaining cost-effective premiums.
Commercial Liability
Commercial general liability insurance covers business-related accidents, injuries, and property damage. We provide policies that protect company assets from common risks including customer injuries, advertising claims, and property damage during business operations. Our solutions adapt to evolving business needs.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance covers water damage from natural flooding events. We educate clients about flood zone requirements and policy specifics including building coverage, personal property protection, and claims processes. Our agency helps businesses and homeowners in both high-risk and moderate-risk areas secure appropriate flood protection.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance solutions to protect families and businesses. Our policies provide death benefits for final expenses, income replacement, and business continuity planning. We help clients evaluate coverage needs based on financial obligations, dependents, and long-term goals.
Workers Compensation
Workers' compensation insurance covers job-related injuries and illnesses. We provide policies that meet state requirements while protecting businesses from liability claims. Our solutions include medical expense coverage, wage replacement, and return-to-work programs for injured employees.
People
Anthony Bacarella
CEO & Agency Owner
With 25+ years in property & casualty insurance, Anthony founded Bacarella Insurance Group in 2007. He specializes in personalized coverage solutions while maintaining community involvement through church outreach and local charity work.
Jonathan Bacarella
Agency Owner
Jonathan brings extensive personal lines experience from State Farm and Allstate. He joined the family business in 2020, focusing on client relationships and expanding insurance offerings while maintaining high service standards.
Questions
What types of insurance do you specialize in?
We specialize in home, auto, commercial liability, flood, and life insurance, along with workers' compensation and recreational vehicle coverage for both personal and business needs.
How do you help clients find the right coverage?
We conduct personalized consultations to understand individual needs, review existing policies for gaps, and compare options from multiple carriers to find cost-effective, comprehensive solutions.
Are you locally owned and operated?
Yes, we're a family-owned agency serving Southwest Florida since 2007, with deep community ties and local market expertise in insurance solutions.
How do you handle insurance claims?
We guide clients through the claims process, helping document losses, communicate with insurers, and ensure timely resolution while advocating for fair settlements.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Fort Myers and Southwest Florida, providing insurance solutions tailored to local climate risks and regulatory requirements.
