Business Details
Trusted Insurance Solutions for Missouri Businesses & Families
At Fortner Insurance, we are a family-owned agency based in Springfield, Missouri, dedicated to providing personalized insurance solutions for churches, businesses, nonprofits, and families across the state. With over 200 years of combined experience, our team prioritizes honest coverage and practical protection tailored to each client's unique needs. Led by co-owners Anthony and Nell Gillen, we combine down-to-earth communication with specialized expertise in church, camp, business, and personal insurance.As an independent agency, we partner with top-rated carriers like Brotherhood Mutual and Liberty Mutual to ensure competitive options without the hassle. Our commitment to building long-term trust through real relationships has made us a trusted resource for Missouri communities since our founding.
Services
Business Insurance
Camp Insurance
Employee Benefits
Life Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Personal Insurance
Church Insurance
Nonprofit Insurance
Highlights and features
- We are a family-owned agency with over 200 years of combined experience.
- We specialize in church and ministry insurance as a Brotherhood Mutual partner.
- Our flexible service includes in-person, phone, and 24/7 online portal access.
- We work with top-rated carriers to find you the best coverage options.
- Our team provides localized expertise for Missouri's unique insurance needs.
Associations and certifications
- Brotherhood Mutual
What people say
Excellent customer service
Personalized attention
Helpful guidance
Best options
Most value
Services
Business Insurance
We provide comprehensive business insurance solutions including general liability, property coverage, and workers' compensation. Our policies protect Missouri businesses from operational risks while ensuring compliance with state requirements. Specialized options like cyber liability and commercial auto insurance help address modern challenges.
Church Insurance
Our church insurance programs offer tailored coverage for faith-based organizations, including property protection, liability safeguards, and specialized ministry risk management. As a Brotherhood Mutual partner, we deliver resources specifically designed for Missouri's religious institutions and their unique needs.
Life Insurance
We offer life insurance policies that provide financial protection for families and dependents. Our options include term and permanent coverage solutions that help Missouri residents create lasting legacies while addressing immediate financial obligations like mortgages and education costs.
Medicare Insurance
Our Medicare specialists help Missouri seniors navigate healthcare options including Advantage plans, Medigap coverage, and Part D prescription drug plans. We provide personalized comparisons to help clients select cost-effective solutions that match their specific medical needs.
Camp Insurance
We specialize in insurance for seasonal and year-round camps across Missouri. Our policies address liability risks, property protection, and specialized coverage for outdoor recreation programs through partnerships with carriers like Brotherhood Mutual and GuideOne.
People
Anthony Gillen
Co-Owner
Anthony Gillen co-leads Fortner Insurance with a focus on building client relationships and delivering practical insurance solutions. He combines industry expertise with a commitment to personalized service for Missouri businesses and families.
Nell Gillen
Co-Owner
Nell Gillen partners with Anthony to provide compassionate insurance guidance. She specializes in connecting Missouri families and ministries with coverage that aligns with their values while maintaining the agency's commitment to honest, straightforward service.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide business, life, Medicare, personal, camp, church, and nonprofit insurance solutions tailored to Missouri residents' specific needs.
How are you different from other insurance agencies?
As a family-owned business with 200+ years of combined experience, we combine personalized service with specialized expertise in church and ministry insurance through our Brotherhood Mutual partnership.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a customized quote through our website forms or contact us directly at (417) 882-5560 for personalized assistance.
Do you serve clients outside Springfield?
Yes, we work with clients across Missouri, including St. Louis, Kansas City, Joplin, and Branson, providing consistent service through in-person visits or our online portal.
How do I file a claim?
Visit our claims page for carrier contact information and next steps, or use our InsureLink portal for 24/7 account access and service requests.
