Business Details
23 Years
experience
Your Trusted Cincinnati Insurance Partner
Advantage Insurance Network is an independent insurance agency representing over 25 top-rated insurance companies. Founded in 2003 by Lewis C. Smith III, we specialize in providing affordable, customized insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. Our technology-driven approach allows us to shop your insurance across multiple carriers to find the best combination of coverage and cost. With offices in Cincinnati, Ohio, we serve clients across Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee, and Michigan. Our team of dedicated agents takes the time to understand your unique needs and provides personalized service backed by decades of industry experience.We offer a comprehensive suite of insurance products, including auto, home, business, life, health, and Medicare policies, ensuring all aspects of your life and business are protected. Our commitment to client satisfaction extends beyond policy issuance, as we proactively re-shop coverage at renewal to maintain competitive rates. When claims arise, our agents act as advocates, guiding clients through the process to ensure fair outcomes. With a focus on transparency, expertise, and local market knowledge, we've built a reputation as a trusted partner for insurance needs.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Commercial Policies
Policy Comparisons
Claims Assistance
Insurance Bundling
Details
- Year established: 2003
Highlights and features
- We represent 25+ top-rated insurance carriers for comprehensive comparisons
- Our tech-driven platform enables instant multi-carrier rate comparisons
- Dedicated agents provide personalized service with local market expertise
- Proactive policy re-shopping ensures continued competitive pricing
- Claims advocacy supports clients through the insurance claims process
What people say
Prompt service
Great rates
Knowledgeable staff
Personalized approach
Quick responses
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions tailored to individual driving profiles and vehicle needs. Our service compares coverage options across multiple carriers to find policies balancing protection and affordability. Clients benefit from personalized guidance on coverage selection, multi-policy discounts, and claims support. With access to both major national providers and regional insurers, we help drivers in Ohio and surrounding states secure appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Our technology platform enables instant rate comparisons while maintaining the personal touch of experienced agents.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance service protects residential properties through customized policies covering structure, personal belongings, and liability risks. We assist homeowners and renters in selecting appropriate coverage levels based on property value, location, and individual needs. The service includes policy comparisons across multiple insurers, guidance on endorsements like flood or earthquake coverage, and assistance with claims documentation. Serving Cincinnati and surrounding areas, we help clients secure competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection against common risks like fire, theft, and weather damage.
Business Insurance
We offer comprehensive business insurance solutions protecting companies across various industries. Our service includes Business Owners Policies (BOPs), liability coverage, workers' compensation, and specialized protections for commercial property, cyber risks, and professional liability. We work with small businesses and large commercial accounts to create tailored risk management strategies. Through relationships with multiple carriers, we help clients find competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection for operational risks. Our agents provide ongoing policy reviews to adapt coverage as businesses grow and evolve.
Life Insurance
We provide life insurance solutions including term, whole, and universal life policies to protect families and businesses. Our service involves assessing clients' financial obligations, dependents' needs, and long-term goals to recommend appropriate coverage amounts and policy types. We work with multiple insurers to offer competitive rates and flexible terms. The process includes policy comparisons, underwriting guidance, and ongoing reviews to ensure coverage remains aligned with changing life circumstances. Clients benefit from personalized explanations of policy features and cash value components.
Medicare Insurance
We specialize in Medicare insurance solutions including Medigap, Advantage, and Prescription Drug Plans. Our service helps clients navigate Medicare options to find coverage matching their healthcare needs and budget. We provide comparative analyses of plan benefits, prescription coverage, and network providers. With expertise in Medicare regulations, we assist with enrollment, plan changes, and understanding out-of-pocket costs. Our ongoing support includes annual reviews to ensure continued alignment with clients' medical requirements and financial situations.
People
Lewis C. Smith III
Founder
With over 20 years of insurance industry experience, Lewis C. Smith III established Advantage Insurance Network in 2003. He leads the agency's strategic direction while maintaining hands-on client relationships. His expertise in risk assessment and policy optimization helps clients secure comprehensive coverage at competitive rates.
Jill Sherman
Insurance Agent
Jill Sherman brings extensive knowledge of personal and commercial insurance products to her role. With 15 years of experience, she specializes in creating customized insurance solutions while maintaining a client retention rate exceeding 95%. Her proactive approach includes annual policy reviews and market comparisons to ensure continued value.
Sara Hummell
Insurance Agent
Sara Hummell combines technical insurance expertise with personalized service. She focuses on building long-term client relationships through transparent communication and thorough policy explanations. Her clients consistently praise her responsiveness and ability to find cost-effective coverage solutions that meet specific needs.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, home, business, life, health, and Medicare insurance with coverage options from 25+ top-rated carriers.
How do you find competitive insurance rates?
Our technology platform compares rates across multiple insurers while our agents use industry expertise to negotiate optimal pricing.
Which states do you serve?
We provide insurance solutions in Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee, and Michigan from our Cincinnati office.
What happens if I need to file a claim?
Our agents act as your advocate during the claims process, guiding you through documentation and resolution steps.
Can I manage policies online?
Yes, our digital platform allows policy management, ID card printing, payments, and 24/7 quote access.
How often should I review my insurance coverage?
We recommend annual reviews or whenever major life changes occur to ensure continued coverage appropriateness.