Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Westerville, Ohio
Kalmbaugh Insurance Agency has been a trusted name in Westerville, Ohio since 1975, delivering personalized insurance solutions with over 150 years of combined expertise among our team. As Certified Insurance Counselors (C.I.C.), we uphold rigorous industry standards through continuous education and national recognition for our specialized knowledge. Our agency prides itself on advocating for clients during claims processes, offering tailored coverage from top-rated carriers like Travelers and Liberty Mutual. With a legacy of 50 years, we maintain a client-centric approach, ensuring policies meet individual needs rather than relying on automated systems.Our team includes seasoned professionals like President John Kalmbaugh, a graduate of The Ohio State University with over five decades of underwriting experience, and specialists in property, casualty, and emerging risks. Recognized by Central Insurance Company with the Blue Streak Circle of Achievement, we combine local insight with nationwide expertise to protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Pet Insurance
Cyber Liability
Umbrella Protection
RV Insurance
Solar Energy Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- 50 years of local insurance expertise since 1975
- Certified Insurance Counselors with rigorous industry training
- Personalized policy customization from top-rated carriers
- Dedicated claims process advocacy for clients
- Recipient of Central Insurance Company's Blue Streak Award
Associations and certifications
- Certified Insurance Counselor (C.I.C.)
- Trusted Choice
What people say
Excellent customer service
Personal effort
Would not choose elsewhere
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your home with customized policies covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability. Our specialists tailor coverage to address local risks in Westerville, Ohio, ensuring comprehensive protection for your primary residence or investment properties.
Business Insurance
Safeguard your enterprise with liability protection, property coverage, and business interruption insurance. We design policies for diverse industries, including specialized solutions for cyber liability and commercial vehicle fleets operating in central Ohio.
Pet Insurance
Secure financial protection against unexpected veterinary expenses for dogs and cats. Our plans cover accidents, illnesses, and preventive care with flexible options to suit different breeds and age groups, providing peace of mind for pet owners.
Cyber Liability
Mitigate digital risks with coverage for data breaches, cyber attacks, and network security failures. Designed for Ohio businesses handling sensitive customer information, this protection includes legal defense costs and regulatory compliance support.
Umbrella Protection
Extend beyond standard policy limits with supplemental liability coverage. This protection safeguards personal and business assets against catastrophic claims exceeding primary insurance coverage amounts, providing critical financial security.
People
John C. Kalmbaugh
President/Certified Insurance Counselor
With over 50 years in insurance, John Kalmbaugh leads our agency as a Certified Insurance Counselor. A Ohio State University graduate, he specializes in underwriting and holds the LUTCF designation, ensuring expert guidance for clients.
Ian Kalmbaugh
Marketing and Communications
Ian Kalmbaugh combines insurance expertise with digital marketing skills in Santa Monica, California. He develops communication strategies while maintaining industry licensing, bridging traditional insurance with modern outreach methods.
Kerry Kalmbaugh
Senior Associate
As a licensed agent, Kerry Kalmbaugh provides detailed policy analysis and client education. With extensive experience in property and casualty insurance, he ensures clients receive well-structured, value-driven coverage solutions.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, auto, business, pet, cyber liability, and specialty insurance including solar energy and umbrella policies.
How do you handle insurance claims?
Our team actively advocates for clients during claims, ensuring timely processing and fair settlements with insurers.
Why choose an independent agent?
As independent agents, we compare multiple carriers to find customized coverage that matches your specific needs and budget.
Do you serve areas beyond Westerville?
While based in Westerville, we provide insurance solutions to clients throughout Ohio and select regional markets.
Videos