Business Details
43 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Jamestown, NY
Gary N Johnson Insurance has been family-owned and operated since 1983, providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and businesses. With over 40 years of experience in the industry, we specialize in offering a wide range of personal and commercial insurance policies tailored to meet the unique needs of our clients. Our team of licensed advisors is committed to delivering exceptional service while maintaining competitive pricing across multiple lines of coverage. As an independent agency, we partner with regional and national carriers to ensure our customers receive comprehensive protection options. Our deep understanding of local risks, combined with our dedication to staying current with industry trends, allows us to provide informed guidance to policyholders in Jamestown, NY, and beyond.We pride ourselves on being more than just an insurance providerwe strive to be your trusted partner in managing risk and protecting what matters most. Our decades-long relationships with carriers and clients alike demonstrate our commitment to long-term value and service excellence. Whether you're seeking personal coverage or business protection, our agency remains dedicated to helping you navigate insurance decisions with confidence.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Auto Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
General Liability Insurance
Renters Insurance
Secondary Home Insurance
Contractor Insurance
Restaurant Insurance
Property Manager Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
- Family-owned agency with 40+ years of local insurance expertise
- Independent representation across multiple regional and national carriers
- Personalized service from licensed insurance advisors
- Licensed in New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Vermont
- Specialized risk management guidance for personal and business needs
Associations and certifications
- Renaissance Alliance
What people say
Quick to handle questions
Professional and kind staff
Competitive rates
Prompt customer service
Easy to work with
Services
Auto Insurance
Protect your vehicle and assets with comprehensive auto insurance solutions. Our policies cover collision, comprehensive, liability, and uninsured motorist protection while offering rental reimbursement options. We help clients select appropriate coverage limits based on individual needs and state requirements, ensuring financial protection against accidents, theft, and unexpected damages through competitive rate comparisons across multiple carriers.
Home Insurance
Secure your primary residence with customizable homeowners insurance policies. Coverage includes structural protection, personal property replacement, liability claims, and additional living expenses during covered displacements. Our advisors help clients understand policy specifics like replacement cost vs. actual cash value, ensuring adequate protection against common risks including fire, weather damage, and liability incidents occurring on insured properties.
Business Insurance
Safeguard commercial operations with tailored business insurance packages. Offerings include general liability, property insurance, business auto, and specialized coverage for industries like contracting, restaurants, and property management. We help businesses mitigate risks through comprehensive policies that protect physical assets, cover liability claims, and maintain operational continuity during unexpected disruptions, working with carriers to meet specific industry requirements.
General Liability Insurance
Protect your business from third-party claims with essential liability coverage. Policies address bodily injury, property damage, and advertising injury claims arising from business operations. We assist clients in determining appropriate coverage limits based on industry standards and contractual requirements, ensuring protection against lawsuits and settlements that could impact financial stability while meeting state-mandated minimums where applicable.
Commercial Property Insurance
Preserve business assets against physical damage and losses. Coverage extends to buildings, equipment, inventory, and furniture damaged by fire, weather events, or vandalism. We help clients evaluate replacement costs and select appropriate policy terms, including business interruption coverage to maintain cash flow during recovery periods, ensuring comprehensive protection for both owned and leased commercial properties.
People
Gary N. Johnson
Founder
With over 50 years in the insurance industry since starting his career in 1969, Gary established our agency in 1983. His extensive experience shapes our commitment to personalized service and competitive coverage solutions for both personal and commercial clients.
Robin Kiendl
Agency Manager
As second-generation leadership, Robin brings decades of hands-on insurance expertise to our agency. She oversees daily operations while maintaining direct client relationships, ensuring our team continues delivering the responsive, personalized service our clients expect since 1983.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, renters), business insurance (general liability, commercial property), and specialized coverage for industries including contracting, restaurants, and property management.
Are you licensed to operate outside New York?
Yes, we're licensed in New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Vermont, serving clients across these states with appropriate insurance solutions.
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Contact us directly at 716-483-5525 or through our website contact form to receive a personalized, no-obligation insurance quote tailored to your specific needs.
What makes you different from other agencies?
As an independent agency with 40+ years of local experience, we combine personalized service with access to multiple carriers to find you optimal coverage at competitive rates.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
While we maintain regular business hours, we guide clients through after-hours emergency procedures and provide prompt assistance during our operating hours for claims-related matters.
