Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Independent Insurance in Outer Banks Since 1957
Outer Banks Insurance Agency has been serving the Outer Banks community since 1957, providing personalized insurance solutions for families and businesses. As a family-owned independent agency, we understand the unique insurance needs of coastal living, offering specialized coverage options including wind, flood, and property insurance. Our team of licensed professionals brings decades of combined experience in coastal insurance matters, working with multiple carriers to secure competitive rates and comprehensive coverage.We are committed to protecting assets and minimizing risk through tailored insurance products, while maintaining the highest standards of integrity and professionalism. Our deep roots in the community and dedication to client satisfaction have made us a trusted partner for generations of Outer Banks residents and businesses.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Flood Insurance
Renter's Insurance
Commercial Liability
Boat Insurance
Wind Insurance
Commercial Property
Life Insurance
Umbrella Policies
Details
- Year established: 1957
Highlights and features
- Family-owned and operated since 1957 with deep community roots
- Specialized knowledge of coastal insurance requirements and challenges
- Access to multiple top-rated insurance carriers for competitive options
- Personalized service from local independent insurance agents who know the Outer Banks
- Dedicated claims support and regular policy reviews for optimal coverage
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance policies protect vehicles against damage from accidents, fire, theft, and natural disasters. Our coverage includes liability protection for medical expenses and property damage, with options tailored to individual driving needs and vehicle types. We help clients select appropriate limits and deductibles while ensuring compliance with North Carolina insurance requirements.
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners insurance safeguards properties against damage from covered perils like wind, hail, fire, and vandalism. We specialize in coastal insurance needs, offering policies that cover building structures, personal property, and liability protection. Our agents help clients understand HOA agreements and select appropriate coverage for primary residences or vacation homes.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance provides financial protection against water damage from flooding events not covered by standard homeowners policies. We offer National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) policies for buildings and contents, helping coastal residents and businesses meet coverage requirements while explaining policy limitations and claim procedures.
Commercial Liability
Commercial liability insurance protects businesses from financial losses due to third-party claims of bodily injury, property damage, or advertising injuries. Our coverage includes general liability, errors and omissions, employment practices liability, and directors and officers insurance to help businesses manage operational risks effectively.
Umbrella Policies
Umbrella insurance policies provide additional liability coverage beyond standard auto or home insurance limits. These policies protect personal and business assets from catastrophic losses, covering legal fees and settlements that exceed primary policy limits while offering cost-effective risk management solutions.
People
Keith Fearing
Founder
M. Keith Fearing, Jr. founded the agency in 1957 by merging two established insurance businesses. A respected community leader, he established the first pharmacy in Dare County and played key roles in developing local infrastructure and insurance legislation for coastal areas.
Malcolm K. Fearing III
Owner
Malcolm K. Fearing III joined the family business after meeting his wife Susan at the Southeastern Insurance Institute. With over 35 years of experience, he continues the family tradition of providing quality insurance services to Outer Banks residents and businesses.
Susan Fearing
Owner
Susan Fearing joined the family business after meeting Malcolm at the Southeastern Insurance Institute. She contributes to the agency's operations and client relationships while maintaining the family's commitment to personalized service in the Outer Banks community.
Kathryn Fearing
Operations Manager
Kathryn Fearing, granddaughter of Keith Fearing, joined the agency in 2009 after graduating from Elon University. She oversees daily operations, focusing on client trust and service excellence while continuing the family's 60-year tradition of quality insurance services.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer personal insurance (auto, home, flood, boat, life) and commercial insurance (liability, property, umbrella, workers' comp) tailored to coastal living needs.
Are you a local insurance agency?
Yes, we're a family-owned Kill Devil Hills agency serving Outer Banks communities since 1957 with specialized knowledge of coastal insurance requirements.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Contact us immediately at 252-441-4077 or 800-535-6242 after documenting damage, making temporary repairs, and preparing property inventories for faster processing.
Do you offer business insurance?
Yes, we provide commercial liability, property, fleet, umbrella policies, and workers' compensation tailored to Outer Banks businesses' unique coastal risks.
What makes you different from other insurers?
As a local independent agency, we combine 65+ years of coastal insurance experience with access to multiple carriers to find personalized coverage solutions at competitive rates.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote through our website or contact our Kill Devil Hills office directly to discuss your specific insurance needs with our experienced agents.