Business Details
38 Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Wilbraham, MA
Stonewall Insurance Group was founded in 1988 with a mission to combat declining customer service standards in the insurance industry. As an independent agency, we specialize in classic and collector car insurance while offering comprehensive coverage for vehicles, homes, boats, aircraft, and businesses. Our team combines over 75 years of collective experience with a passion for personalized service, ensuring policies are tailored to individual needs rather than generic templates. We maintain partnerships with top-tier insurers to secure competitive pricing and optimal coverage for clients across all 50 states. Our commitment to transparency includes proactive policy reviews to ensure ongoing value and protection.With a heritage rooted in automotive enthusiasm, we extend our expertise to niche markets like restoration shops and collector vehicle clubs. Our technology infrastructure supports seamless policy management while maintaining the human touch that defines our customer relationships. We measure success through long-term client retention, with 99.25% of customers renewing annually. Our affiliations with industry leaders like AIG and Hagerty reflect our dedication to quality. Headquartered in Wilbraham, Massachusetts, we serve both individual collectors and commercial clients nationwide.
Services
Classic Car Insurance
Auto Insurance
Boat Insurance
Aircraft Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Business Insurance
Renters Insurance
Landlord Insurance
Condo Insurance
Flood Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1988
Highlights and features
- We tailor each policy to your specific needs, ensuring adequate coverage without unnecessary costs
- We offer a one-stop shop for all your insurance needs including vehicles, businesses, and properties
- Our independent status lets us shop multiple carriers to find you the best price
- We provide personalized service backed by 75+ years of combined industry experience
- Our bundling options save clients up to 25% on combined policies
What people say
Personal service fantastic pricing
Great service. Highly recommend.
Best of the best!
Easy policy understanding
Proactive coverage updates
Services
Classic Car Insurance
Specialized insurance for vintage and collector vehicles with agreed value protection. Our policies cover show cars, daily drivers, and investment-grade automobiles. We understand unique risks associated with classic cars and offer flexible terms for enthusiasts nationwide.
Business Insurance
Tailored protection for commercial operations including liability, property, and workers' compensation. We serve niche markets like restoration shops and collector vehicle clubs. Our policies address unique business risks while providing competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships.
Aircraft Insurance
Comprehensive insurance for private and commercial aircraft operations. We offer specialized policies for vintage planes and modern fleets. Our aviation experts work with top-rated insurers to provide hull coverage, liability protection, and risk management solutions.
Homeowners Insurance
Customizable coverage for primary residences and investment properties. Our policies protect against common risks while accommodating unique features. We offer standard and specialty options including flood insurance and high-value home coverage.
Boat Insurance
Protection for recreational and commercial watercraft including yachts and classic boats. Policies cover physical damage, liability, and uninsured boater scenarios. We provide specialized marine insurance through dedicated underwriters with decades of industry experience.
People
Jeff DeMarey
President
With 40 years in insurance and automotive expertise, Jeff leads as President. He serves on the National Board of Directors for the Classic Car Club of America and founded the Springfield to Boston Education Foundation to promote classic car education for youth.
Lori Sheehan
VP Personal Lines
Lori brings 25+ years of underwriting and personal lines experience. A muscle car enthusiast, she uniquely combines technical insurance knowledge with hands-on automotive passion to serve clients' personal insurance needs effectively.
Stacy Puckett Taylor
Commercial Lines
Stacy holds a degree in Automotive Restoration Technology and has international experience in classic car preservation. Her background includes roles at Mercedes Benz Classic Center and LeMay Museum, bringing specialized knowledge to commercial insurance solutions.
Chris DeMarey
Marketing Manager
A Bryant University graduate, Chris manages digital marketing and web operations. He actively participates in automotive events as a judge at prestigious concours events while leading the agency's online presence initiatives.
Shawn Jones
I.T. Director
With 35 years in IT, Shawn oversees all technology infrastructure. He has implemented secure systems for policy management and client communications, ensuring modern digital solutions support the agency's traditional service values.
Questions
What makes Stonewall different from other insurance agencies?
As an independent agency, we're not tied to any single insurer. This allows us to compare multiple carriers to find you the best coverage at competitive prices while maintaining personalized service.
Do you offer discounts for bundling policies?
Yes, our bundling options save clients up to 25% when combining multiple policies. This applies to vehicle, home, business, and other insurance types we offer.
Can you insure specialty vehicles outside your classic car focus?
We insure all vehicle types including motorcycles, boats, aircraft, and modern cars. Our specialty is matching unique needs with appropriate coverage solutions through our carrier network.
How do you handle policy reviews and updates?
We proactively monitor your coverage needs and available options. Our team contacts clients when better deals emerge or when policy adjustments would better suit changing circumstances.
What areas do you serve?
We operate nationwide across all 50 states, providing insurance solutions for clients from local Wilbraham residents to national businesses and collectors.
Videos
