Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Beaverton, MI
Schumacher Insurance has been serving Beaverton and the surrounding areas since 1953, offering comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. Our team of licensed professionals brings decades of combined experience, prioritizing exceptional customer service and personalized coverage options. We represent multiple reputable insurance carriers to provide competitive rates and robust protection for home, auto, life, and commercial policies. With two convenient locations in Beaverton and Clare, our agency emphasizes community involvement and long-term client relationships.Our staff maintains specialized certifications, including Certified Professional Insurance Agent (CPIA) and Certified Authority on Workers' Compensation (CAWC), ensuring expertise across diverse insurance domains. We pride ourselves on simplifying the insurance process through transparent communication and dedicated support, reflecting our commitment to dependability and trustworthiness.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Workers' Compensation
Surety Bonds
Health Insurance
Rental Insurance
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1953
Highlights and features
- We offer 70+ years of combined insurance expertise serving Michigan communities
- Our team holds specialized industry certifications including CPIA and CAWC designations
- We provide personalized coverage options from multiple top-rated insurance carriers
- Our local agents maintain deep knowledge of Michigan-specific insurance requirements
- We operate two convenient office locations in Beaverton and Clare, MI
Associations and certifications
- Certified Professional Insurance Agent (CPIA)
- Certified Authority on Workers' Compensation (CAWC)
What people say
Knowledgeable staff
Personalized service
Community commitment
Multiple locations
Professional agents
Services
Personal Insurance
We provide comprehensive personal insurance solutions protecting Michigan residents' homes, vehicles, and families. Our offerings include auto, home, renters, and recreational vehicle insurance with customizable coverage options. Our agents help clients combine policies for premium discounts while ensuring adequate protection against common risks.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance services protect Michigan businesses through property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage. We specialize in creating tailored risk management strategies for local businesses and offer surety bonding solutions. Our experienced agents understand industry-specific insurance requirements and help clients maintain compliance while protecting their operations.
Life Insurance
We offer life insurance policies designed to protect families against financial hardship from unexpected loss. Our solutions include term and permanent life insurance options with flexible premium structures. Our licensed agents help clients evaluate coverage needs based on family circumstances, debts, and long-term financial goals.
Workers' Compensation
Our certified specialists provide workers' compensation insurance solutions for Michigan businesses. We help employers meet legal requirements while protecting employees through comprehensive coverage for work-related injuries. Our services include policy customization, risk assessment, and claims support for various industries.
Surety Bonds
We offer surety bond solutions for Michigan businesses requiring contractual guarantees. Our services cover contract bonds, license and permit bonds, and court bonds. Our experienced agents help clients navigate bonding requirements for construction projects, regulatory compliance, and legal obligations.
People
Jeff Johnston
President
President Jeff Johnston has served Schumacher Insurance since 1992, bringing extensive industry experience and community leadership. He graduated from Michigan Tech University and actively participates in local service groups, balancing family life with three sons and his wife.
Tony Smith
Licensed Agent
Licensed Agent Tony Smith has worked at Schumacher since 2015, offering expertise in property and casualty insurance. A Beaverton native with a BS in Food Industry Management from Michigan State, he serves as Lions Club President and enjoys outdoor activities.
Amy Tenwalde
Licensed Agent
Licensed Agent Amy Tenwalde has served the agency since 2012, specializing in property and casualty insurance. A lifelong Beaverton resident with an Associates degree in Small Business Management, she balances family life with community involvement.
Kelsey Redman
Commercial Lines Specialist
Commercial Lines Specialist Kelsey Redman joined Schumacher in 2013, earning her CAWC certification. She graduated from Clare High School and Mid Michigan College, actively participating in community events while balancing family life with her son.
Steve Carland
Vice President
Vice President Steve Carland has worked at Schumacher since 2010, transitioning from education to insurance. He graduated from SVSU and Ferris State, focusing on community engagement through Rotary and youth sports coaching.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, life, renters), commercial insurance (property, liability, workers' compensation), and surety bonds for Michigan residents and businesses.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact us through our website form, call either office location, or visit in person during business hours for a customized insurance consultation.
Are your agents licensed and certified?
Yes, all our agents hold valid property and casualty licenses, with additional certifications including CPIA and CAWC designations for specialized expertise.
Do you serve areas outside Beaverton?
We serve clients throughout Central Michigan, including Clare and surrounding communities, from our two office locations.
What sets your agency apart from others?
Our 70+ years of local experience, multiple carrier options, and community-focused approach differentiate us in providing tailored insurance solutions.
