Business Details
21 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Scarsdale, NY
Select Agency is a family-owned business that has provided specialized insurance solutions for over 20 years. Our expertise lies in tailoring coverage for niche industries such as pest control operators and landscapers/lawn care providers, with a client base exceeding 5,000 pest control accounts nationwide. We prioritize personalized service, conducting detailed interviews to understand each client's unique risks before recommending policies from top-rated carriers. Licensed in most U.S. states, our team combines the agility of a small business with the resources of a national agency, ensuring direct access to decision-makers and rapid response times.Our owners, Phillis and Frank MacDonald, bring decades of industry experience, having previously worked as pest control professionals themselves. We maintain affiliations with major industry associations and focus on long-term client relationships built on trust, transparency, and comprehensive risk management.
Services
Pest Control Insurance
Landscapers Insurance
Commercial Property Coverage
Personal Home Insurance
Commercial Auto Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2005
Highlights and features
- We offer 20+ years of specialized expertise in pest control and landscaping insurance
- Our team provides personalized policy development through client interviews
- Coverage available in 44+ U.S. states with rapid response times
- Owners have direct industry experience as former pest control professionals
- We maintain partnerships with top-rated insurance carriers for optimal coverage
Associations and certifications
- National Pest Control Association
- A.M. Best (A-rated carriers)
What people say
Personal attention
Industry expertise
Reliable support
Long-term trust
Comprehensive coverage
Services
Pest Control Insurance
Specialized insurance for pest control operators with occurrence-based policies from A-rated carriers. Covers liability, pollution, equipment, and business risks. Includes advertising injury, non-owned water liabilities, and microbial matter coverage up to $1M. Designed for businesses ranging from small operations to multi-million dollar companies.
Landscapers Insurance
Customized protection for landscaping professionals including liability, equipment, and vehicle coverage. Features business auto policies, equipment floaters, and workers' compensation. Addresses risks from dangerous machinery and fleet management needs while providing comprehensive protection for property damage and operational liabilities.
Commercial Property Coverage
Tailored insurance plans assessing business-specific risks to protect physical assets. Includes fire legal liability, premises medical payments, and blanket additional insured provisions. Combines property protection with liability coverage for commercial operations across various industries.
Personal Home Insurance
Comprehensive protection for homeowners, condominiums, and landlords with customizable policies. Offers coverage for dwellings, personal property, and liability risks. Includes specialized options for fine arts, valuable articles, and classic vehicles while maintaining competitive premiums through multiple carrier partnerships.
Commercial Auto Insurance
Vehicle coverage solutions for businesses with single or multiple commercial vehicles. Provides protection against liability, collision, and pollution risks. Includes specialized coverage for equipment transport and job-site operations while offering flexible policies adaptable to various business vehicle requirements.
People
Phillis MacDonald
Owner
With over 20 years in the insurance industry, Phillis MacDonald co-founded Select Agency. Former pest control professional brings firsthand industry knowledge to policy development. Maintains longstanding client relationships and focuses on risk assessment tailored to business-specific needs.
Frank MacDonald
Owner
Co-owner Frank MacDonald works closely with clients to match them with appropriate carriers. Leverages industry experience and licensing across multiple states to provide comprehensive coverage solutions. Focuses on personalized service and long-term client partnerships.
Ken Unger
President, Suburban Pest Control
15-year client of Select Insurance praises their buying power and personalized service. Highlights their ability to resolve coverage issues and provide comprehensive protection for auto, workers' compensation, and liability needs.
Randy Abbitt
President, National Exterminating Co.
20+ year client credits Select Insurance with supporting business growth from $650k to $7M annually. Commends Phillis MacDonald's industry knowledge and availability for addressing insurance needs and risk management strategies.
Joe Pestana
President, JP Pest Services
Client since 2012 praises Select's industry expertise and proactive risk management advice. Highlights their understanding of business exposures and commitment to client interests as if managing their own company.
Questions
What industries does Select Insurance specialize in?
We specialize in insurance for pest control operators, landscapers/lawn care professionals, and commercial property owners. We also provide personal home and auto insurance.
In how many states do you provide coverage?
Our insurance services are available in 44+ U.S. states, with licensing capabilities across most jurisdictions.
How do you tailor insurance policies to individual businesses?
We conduct detailed client interviews to understand specific risks before recommending customized coverage solutions from our network of A-rated carriers.
What sets Select Insurance apart from competitors?
We combine family-owned personalized service with national reach, industry-specific expertise from former pest control professionals, and direct access to decision-makers.
How do you handle insurance claims?
We provide direct support through our experienced team, leveraging relationships with top-rated carriers to ensure timely resolution of claims.
Can you help with specialized insurance needs?
Yes, we offer specialized coverage including microbial matter policies, canine mortality, and customized endorsements for unique business exposures.
