Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner Since 1879
Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage has been a trusted name in insurance brokerage since 1879, founded on the principles of client-centric service and industry expertise. Our company stock is held in trust for the benefit of clients and associates, reflecting our commitment to transparency and accountability. We provide thoughtful counsel and relentless advocacy, delivering competitive insurance products while fostering an empowering workplace environment. With a legacy of community engagement and recognition as a top workplace in insurance, we combine historical stability with innovative risk management solutions tailored to evolving client needs. 
Services
Commercial Insurance
Personal Insurance
Employee Benefits
Risk Management
Surety Bonds
Construction Insurance
Healthcare Coverage
Manufacturing Protection
Technology Insurance
Private Client Services
Highlights and features
- We offer 150+ years of insurance expertise with industry-specific risk management solutions
- Our client-first approach includes personalized coverage tailored to unique business needs
- We maintain top-tier carrier partnerships for competitive pricing and comprehensive protection
- Our team provides dedicated claims advocacy and 24/7 accessibility for urgent matters
- Recognized as a Top 100 Brokerage firm by Business Insurance Magazine
What people say
Excellent service
Knowledgeable team
Prompt follow-up
Customized solutions
Trusted partner
Services
Commercial Insurance
We provide comprehensive commercial insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes, from startups to established enterprises. Our offerings include property insurance, liability protection, and specialized coverage for industries like construction, manufacturing, and technology. With tailored risk management strategies and access to top-tier carriers, we help businesses protect their assets while maintaining cost-effectiveness.
Personal Insurance
Our personal insurance services offer customized protection for individuals and families, including high-net-worth home policies and luxury asset coverage. We address unique risk exposures through specialized programs for valuable possessions, domestic staff, and estate planning. Our concierge-level service includes annual reviews and claim advocacy to ensure comprehensive protection for clients' personal assets.
Employee Benefits
We design comprehensive employee benefits packages that balance employer needs with employee satisfaction. Our services include health insurance programs, retirement planning, and voluntary benefits tailored to different business sizes. Through strategic partnerships, we offer access to private exchanges and compliance support to help employers navigate complex regulatory requirements while maintaining competitive benefits programs.
Risk Management
Our risk management services combine industry expertise with customized solutions for diverse sectors. We conduct thorough risk assessments, develop mitigation strategies, and provide specialized programs for construction projects, healthcare providers, and manufacturing operations. Our approach focuses on preventing losses while ensuring appropriate coverage for unavoidable risks through tailored insurance solutions.
Surety Bonds
We offer surety bond solutions with access to leading carriers and industry-specific expertise. Our team provides bid bonds, performance bonds, and payment bonds for construction projects, along with specialized bonding solutions for various industries. With a reputation for professionalism in the surety industry, we help businesses secure necessary bonds while maintaining competitive pricing and reliable service.
People
Michael Prentiss
Insurance Professional
Experienced insurance broker specializing in commercial risk management with deep expertise in manufacturing and industrial sectors. Known for responsive service and customized coverage solutions that reduce client costs while improving protection.
Questions
What types of insurance does Starkweather & Shepley offer?
We provide commercial insurance, personal insurance, employee benefits solutions, surety bonds, and specialized risk management programs across multiple industries including construction, healthcare, and technology.
How does Starkweather & Shepley differ from other insurance brokers?
With 150+ years of experience and 14 regional offices, we combine local expertise with national resources to deliver personalized service, industry-specific knowledge, and comprehensive coverage options tailored to client needs.
Can you help with insurance claims?
Yes, we provide dedicated claims advocacy services with experienced professionals who guide clients through the claims process and work directly with carriers to ensure timely, fair resolutions.
Do you serve businesses outside New England?
While headquartered in Rhode Island, we serve clients nationwide through strategic partnerships and have specialized programs available in all 50 states.
How do you handle customized insurance solutions?
Our team conducts thorough risk assessments to understand specific exposures, then designs tailored coverage programs that address unique business or personal requirements while maintaining cost-effectiveness.
