Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Fort Myers, FL
Wilcox Family Insurance has been serving clients in Southwest Florida for over 25 years, establishing itself as one of the largest independent homeowners insurance agencies in the region. Founded by David Wilcox, our family-owned business operates from Fort Myers, FL, and prioritizes personalized service over commission-driven sales. Our team of non-commissioned agents works directly for clients, not insurance companies, ensuring unbiased recommendations. With an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and Trusted Choice designation, we have earned the trust of thousands of loyal customers through hundreds of four- and five-star reviews.Our expertise spans auto, home, health, business, and specialty insurance products, tailored to meet the unique needs of residents and businesses in Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Naples, and throughout South Florida. We maintain strong relationships with top-rated carriers like Progressive, Travelers, and Geico to provide competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage. Our commitment to treating every client like family remains central to our approach, ensuring exceptional service during policy purchases, claims processing, and ongoing support.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Health Insurance
Business Insurance
Commercial Property Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Personal Umbrella Insurance
Recreational Vehicle Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Highlights and features
- We have over 25 years of experience in the insurance industry.
- Our family-owned agency prioritizes personalized service over commissions.
- We work for clients, not insurance companies, as an independent agency.
- Our team maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.
- We offer coverage through top-rated carriers like Progressive and Travelers.
Associations and certifications
- Better Business Bureau
- Trusted Choice
What people say
Always helpful and friendly
Great customer service
Treat me like family
Excellent in-person representative
Prompt and courteous
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance protects Florida properties against common perils like storms, fires, and theft. We specialize in coastal property coverage, including flood and hurricane insurance, while offering standard protections for dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses. Our agents tailor policies to meet specific needs in Fort Myers, Cape Coral, and surrounding areas.
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance coverage meeting Florida's legal requirements and beyond. Our policies include liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protections. We help clients understand deductibles, claims processes, and state-mandated minimums while offering competitive rates through multiple carriers for personal and commercial vehicles.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect companies across Southwest Florida with general liability, property, auto, workers' compensation, and group health coverage. We help businesses assess risk management needs, secure appropriate policies, and maintain compliance with industry regulations while providing personalized support for claims and policy adjustments.
Medicare Insurance
We assist Medicare-eligible clients in selecting appropriate coverage options, including Original Medicare, Advantage plans, and supplemental policies. Our agents explain eligibility requirements, coverage differences, and prescription drug options while helping clients navigate enrollment processes and coverage gaps.
Umbrella Insurance
Our umbrella insurance provides additional liability protection beyond standard policy limits. This coverage applies to both personal and commercial policies, safeguarding assets against major claims from bodily injuries, property damage, lawsuits, and reputational harm while offering financial security beyond primary insurance policies.
People
David Wilcox
Owner/Founder
With 25+ years in insurance, David founded our agency to combine corporate-level options with personalized service. He established our Fort Myers office and mentored the current leadership team to maintain family-centric values.
Jessica Williams
Owner/Manager
Raised in Cape Coral, Jessica co-leads daily operations while maintaining exceptional client service standards. She continues her father's legacy of integrity and personalized insurance solutions for residential and commercial clients.
Mark Wilcox
Owner/Manager
Mark co-owns the agency and oversees operational excellence while upholding family values. With deep local roots, he ensures our team maintains the highest service standards for all personal and business insurance needs.
Paul Salvatore
Customer Service Representative
Paul provides expert policy assistance and claims support, leveraging extensive insurance knowledge to help clients understand coverage options and navigate insurance processes efficiently.
Steven Tague
Agent
Steven offers personalized insurance solutions, specializing in matching clients with optimal coverage. He focuses on clear communication and thorough policy explanations to ensure clients make informed insurance decisions.
Questions
What types of insurance does Wilcox Family Insurance Company offer?
We provide auto, home, health, business, commercial property, Medicare, recreational vehicle, and umbrella insurance policies for clients in Southwest Florida.
Why choose an independent insurance agency?
As an independent agency, we work for you rather than specific insurance companies, allowing us to shop multiple carriers for optimal coverage and pricing.
Do you serve areas outside Fort Myers?
We serve Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Naples, and all South Florida communities from our main office location.
How quickly can I get an insurance quote?
Request instant online quotes for homeowners, auto, or flood insurance, or contact our office for personalized assistance within minutes during business hours.
What should I do after an insurance claim?
Contact our office immediately for claims assistance. We'll guide you through documentation requirements and work directly with carriers to expedite claim resolution.
Are your insurance agents non-commissioned?
Yes, our agents work without commissions to ensure unbiased recommendations focused solely on finding the best coverage for your specific needs.
Videos
