Business Details
16 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Zanesville, OH
At Sarah Wickerham, we prioritize personalized service tailored to each client's unique needs. With over 60 years of combined experience, our team specializes in Auto, Home, Life, Health, and Business insurance solutions. We serve Southeastern Ohio, focusing on Muskingum, Licking, Perry, and Guernsey counties, while maintaining deep community ties through local involvement. Our approach emphasizes transparency, integrity, and 24/7 accessibility via phone, email, or virtual meetings.We pride ourselves on helping clients navigate insurance decisions with confidence, offering no-obligation quotes and comprehensive coverage reviews. Our commitment extends beyond transactionswe actively support local charities like Big Brothers Big Sisters and Eastside Community Ministry. As a State Farm-affiliated agency, we combine national resources with neighborhood-level service, ensuring clients receive both expert guidance and personalized care.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Pet Insurance
Renters Insurance
Condo Insurance
Boat Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2010
Highlights and features
- We provide personalized insurance solutions based on your unique needs
- Our team has 60+ years of combined insurance experience
- Available 24/7 via phone, email, or virtual meetings
- Specialize in protecting families and businesses in Southeastern Ohio
- Active community supporters with local charitable involvement
What people say
Great service
Knowledgeable staff
Competitive rates
24/7 availability
Community commitment
Services
Auto Insurance
We offer comprehensive auto insurance solutions protecting drivers across Southeastern Ohio. Our policies cover liability, collision, and comprehensive risks while offering discounts for safe driving and multi-policy bundling. Our experienced team helps clients understand coverage options and select plans matching their driving habits and budget needs. With 24/7 claims support, we ensure prompt assistance following accidents or vehicle damage incidents.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance provides coverage for residential properties against common risks like fire, theft, and weather damage. Policies include dwelling protection, personal property coverage, and liability protection. We help clients customize coverage based on home value, location, and specific needs like valuable possessions or home-based businesses. Annual policy reviews ensure coverage evolves with changing circumstances.
Life Insurance
We provide term and permanent life insurance solutions to protect families' financial futures. Our specialists help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on income replacement needs, mortgage protection, and inheritance goals. Policies can include additional riders for critical illness or disability coverage. We serve clients during life transitions like marriage, childbirth, or career changes.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance packages protect local companies against operational risks. Coverage includes general liability, property insurance, and business interruption protection. We specialize in policies for small to mid-sized businesses in Southeastern Ohio, addressing industry-specific risks for retail, service providers, and contractors. Annual risk assessments help maintain adequate coverage as businesses grow.
Pet Insurance
We offer pet insurance plans covering veterinary expenses for accidents, illnesses, and chronic conditions. Policies help manage unexpected medical costs while allowing flexibility in choosing veterinary providers. Our team explains coverage limitations regarding pre-existing conditions and helps clients understand reimbursement structures. We work with multiple providers to find plans matching different pet ownership situations.
People
Sarah Wickerham
Owner
Sarah Wickerham founded the agency in 2010 after relocating to Muskingum County. With State Farm since 2010, she actively supports local charities including Big Brothers Big Sisters. Sarah serves on community boards and specializes in personalized insurance planning for families and businesses.
Mary Touvell
Multiple Line Representative
Mary has served State Farm policyholders since 2008, specializing in home, auto, and business insurance. She helps clients protect families through life insurance and paycheck protection plans. A Zanesville resident, Mary combines insurance expertise with community involvement through fitness advocacy and family life.
Mikayla Nash
Multiple Line Representative
Mikayla joined the team in 2022 after obtaining her insurance license. She transitioned from office management to client services, focusing on new business appointments and coverage reviews. Active in local church activities, she balances work with family time while maintaining professional development in insurance services.
Reagan Dygert
Office Manager
Reagan became office manager in 2023 while earning her insurance license. She specializes in claims assistance and client relations. A former educator, she applies teaching skills to explain insurance concepts clearly. Reagan contributes to community theater while managing office operations and client service standards.
Marlie Baker
Marketing Assistant
Marlie joined in 2025 as part-time marketing assistant while completing high school. She coordinates annual policy reviews and client communications. A student-athlete on the Tri-Valley Girls Varsity Soccer team, she balances work with academics and family time in her local community.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, business, pet, condo, renters, boat, and recreational vehicle insurance. Our specialists help clients select appropriate coverage for personal and commercial needs.
Are you available outside regular business hours?
Yes, we offer 24/7 service through phone, text, or email. Emergency claims assistance and virtual meetings accommodate clients' schedules beyond standard office hours.
Do you serve clients outside Zanesville?
We primarily serve Southeastern Ohio including Muskingum, Licking, Perry, and Guernsey counties. Our virtual meeting options allow service to clients throughout Ohio regardless of location.
How can I get a personalized quote?
Contact us via phone, email, or our website to schedule a consultation. Our agents will review your needs and provide customized insurance recommendations with clear pricing options.
What sets your agency apart from competitors?
Our combination of 60+ years collective experience, local community involvement, and personalized service creates lasting client relationships. We focus on understanding individual needs rather than offering generic solutions.
Can I manage policies online?
While we prioritize personal service, State Farm provides online tools for policy management, claims reporting, and payment processing. Our team assists clients with digital platform navigation when needed.
