Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Florida Insurance Partner Since 1974
Founded in 1974 by Jerry Sihle, our agency has built a legacy of treating clients, employees, and partners with integrity. Starting as a small family-owned operation, weve grown into one of Floridas leading insurance brokers while maintaining our commitment to personalized service. Our team of experienced professionals offers tailored solutions across business, personal, and employee benefits insurance, leveraging decades of industry expertise to deliver value-driven coverage.We prioritize transparency, ethical practices, and long-term relationships, ensuring clients receive comprehensive protection aligned with their unique needs. With 10 locations and over 200 dedicated staff, we combine local knowledge with national resources to provide unmatched support in risk management and insurance solutions.
Services
Business Insurance
Personal Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Homeowner Insurance
Medicare
Commercial Property Insurance
Auto Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Employee Benefits
Details
- Year established: 1974
Highlights and features
- We offer over 50 years of experience in Florida insurance markets.
- Our team includes certified professionals with expertise in commercial and personal lines.
- We provide access to a wide network of top-rated insurance carriers.
- Our family-owned agency prioritizes personalized service over corporate bureaucracy.
- We specialize in customized risk management solutions for businesses of all sizes.
What people say
Amazing staff ready to help
Cut homeowners insurance by 50%
Top notch agency
Family owned and operated
Seasoned knowledgeable employees
Services
Business Insurance
We provide tailored commercial insurance solutions protecting Florida businesses from property damage, liability claims, and operational risks. Our services include risk assessment, policy customization, and claims advocacy. With expertise in industries ranging from construction to healthcare, we ensure comprehensive protection aligned with specific business needs while maintaining competitive pricing through major carriers.
Employee Benefits
Our employee benefits division specializes in designing comprehensive health and wellness packages for Florida employers. We offer group medical, dental, vision, and disability plans with flexible options for businesses of all sizes. Our consultants help navigate compliance requirements, implement cost-effective solutions, and provide ongoing support for both employers and employees through the entire benefits lifecycle.
Homeowner Insurance
We offer customized homeowner insurance policies protecting Florida residences from hurricane damage, theft, and other common risks. Coverage includes structural protection, personal property replacement, and liability safeguards. Our agents help clients understand policy details, select appropriate coverage limits, and access specialized options for high-value items or unique property features while ensuring competitive pricing.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance services provide financial protection for families and business partners through term and permanent policy options. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on income replacement needs, debt obligations, and legacy goals. Our specialists explain policy features clearly and assist in selecting carriers offering strong financial ratings and competitive premium rates.
Commercial Property Insurance
We specialize in commercial property coverage protecting Florida businesses from physical damage to buildings, equipment, and inventory. Policies address risks like hurricane impact, fire, and vandalism while offering optional coverage for business interruption losses. Our team works closely with clients to assess asset values, determine appropriate deductibles, and structure policies that balance protection needs with budgetary considerations.
People
Jerry Sihle
Founder
Founded Sihle Insurance Group in 1974 after gaining extensive experience at major insurers. Prioritized people-first values that shaped the agency's growth into a leading Florida brokerage.
Mike Sihle
President
Leads agency operations with decades of insurance industry experience, continuing the family tradition of personalized service and business integrity established by his father Jerry.
Ken Riccard
Chief Operating Officer
Manages day-to-day operations with over 25 years of leadership experience in insurance brokerage, focusing on maintaining service excellence across all client interactions.
Greg Nulph
Chief Financial Officer
Oversees financial operations with expertise in insurance accounting and risk management, ensuring the agency's financial stability while supporting client-focused initiatives.
Terry Singleton
Executive Vice President, Benefits
Benefits specialist with 25+ years of consulting experience, leading employee benefits solutions and serving as equity partner in national advisory organization United Benefit Advisors.
Questions
What types of insurance does Sihle offer?
We provide business insurance (property, auto, liability), personal insurance (home, auto, life, health), employee benefits, and specialty coverage like umbrella policies and Medicare plans.
How can I get a quote?
Request a quote online through our website or contact our Altamonte Springs office directly at 407-869-0962 for personalized assistance.
Do you serve businesses outside Florida?
While our primary focus is Florida, we partner with national carriers to provide coverage solutions for businesses operating across multiple states.
What sets Sihle apart from other agencies?
As a family-owned agency with 50+ years of local experience, we combine personalized service with access to major insurance carriers and innovative risk management solutions.
How do I file a claim?
Contact our claims department directly at our main office number (407-869-0962) or through your dedicated agent for prompt assistance with the claims process.
Do you offer group health insurance for small businesses?
Yes, we specialize in customized group health plans for businesses of all sizes, including small employers, with access to voluntary benefits and wellness programs.
