Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in St. Davids, PA
Robert McIntyre Insurance is a full-service independent insurance agency dedicated to safeguarding the assets of individuals and businesses. With over four decades of experience, we specialize in crafting comprehensive insurance programs tailored to meet evolving needs. Our team combines deep industry expertise with personalized service, leveraging strong relationships with leading insurers to deliver customized solutions.

We prioritize client education, proactive risk management, and community engagement, ensuring our clients receive both protection and value. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our continuous evaluation of coverage requirements and our innovative online tools that simplify policy management.
Services
Commercial Insurance Personal Insurance Risk Management Life Insurance Property Insurance
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 40 years of experience in customized insurance solutions.
  • Our team provides personalized service through strong carrier relationships.
  • We deliver innovative online risk management tools for client convenience.
  • Our advisors hold industry certifications like Certified Insurance Counselor.
  • We prioritize community involvement and client education.
Services
Commercial Insurance
Commercial Insurance protects businesses from risks like property damage, liability, and workers' compensation claims. We design customized plans for industries ranging from retail to manufacturing. Our solutions ensure compliance and financial security while adapting to evolving business needs.
Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance covers homes, vehicles, and assets with flexible policies. We offer bundled packages for auto, homeowners, and umbrella coverage to maximize savings and protection. Our advisors ensure policies adapt to life changes like new family members or property purchases.
Risk Management
Risk Management services help businesses identify and mitigate potential threats. Through RMI Connect, clients access OSHA tools, compliance resources, and peer benchmarks. Our strategies reduce insurance costs and enhance operational resilience for long-term stability.
Life Insurance
Life Insurance policies provide financial security for families and businesses. We offer term and permanent options with competitive rates for nonsmokers and health-conscious clients. Coverage can support mortgages, retirement, or education funding needs.
Property Insurance
Property Insurance safeguards physical assets like homes, condos, and boats. We provide replacement cost coverage, valuables protection, and rental insurance. Policies are designed to recover from losses while minimizing out-of-pocket expenses.
People
Paul M. OConnell, Jr.
President
With over 30 years in insurance, Paul leads RMIs client-focused approach. He holds a Certified Insurance Counselor designation and serves on Harleysvilles Agent Council, prioritizing customer service and competitive policies.
McLeod F. Gwynette
Chairman of the Board
Cloudy Gwynette, with 40+ years in insurance, contributes to local fire and rotary organizations. He graduated from Erskine College and maintains a Certified Insurance Counselor designation, supporting RMIs community ties.
Michael A. Puleo
Vice President
Mike Puleo brings 50+ years of industry experience, joining RMI in 2011 after co-owning Puleo-McFadden Insurance. He specializes in commercial risk solutions and client relationship management.
Vincent C. OConnell
Advisor
Vince OConnell, a Certified Insurance Counselor since 2013, focuses on business development and client education. He graduated from Shippensburg University and serves on local business networks.
Thomas J. Kirby
Advisor
Tom Kirby offers 50+ years of insurance expertise, specializing in commercial and personal risk management. He holds a BA from Temple University and provides tailored coverage solutions for RMI clients.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide commercial insurance, personal insurance, life insurance, and risk management services tailored to individual and business needs.
How can I access my policy information?
Log in to RMI Connect, our client portal, to manage policies, file claims, and access risk management resources.
Do you offer discounts on insurance packages?
Yes, bundling policies like auto and home insurance can provide discounts and simplified coverage.
How do I file a claim?
Contact our office directly or use our claims hotline to report incidents and receive guidance through the process.
Are your agents certified?
Our team includes Certified Insurance Counselors and professionals with decades of industry experience.
What risk management tools are available?
RMI Connect offers OSHA reporting, workers' compensation resources, and peer comparison tools for business clients.