Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Indianapolis, IN
Founded in 1949, Tom Plummer Agency has built a legacy of trust and expertise in the insurance industry, serving clients across Indiana. Our agency operates with a client-first philosophy, prioritizing personalized service and comprehensive coverage solutions tailored to individual and business needs. With over seven decades of experience, we leverage deep industry knowledge to analyze existing policies, identify coverage gaps, and recommend improvements that align with our clients' unique circumstances. As an independent agency, we maintain partnerships with a diverse network of carriers, enabling us to offer competitive rates and a wide array of insurance productsfrom auto and homeowners policies to specialized commercial coverage. Our team of dedicated professionals is committed to staying informed about evolving insurance trends and regulations, ensuring clients receive accurate, up-to-date advice.We emphasize transparency in all interactions, providing objective analyses and straightforward guidance to help clients navigate complex insurance decisions. Our streamlined claims and payment processes, including automatic payment options and simplified reporting, reflect our dedication to convenience and efficiency. With four generations of family leadership, we uphold a tradition of ethical service and community engagement, fostering long-term relationships built on reliability and mutual respect. Whether protecting personal assets or safeguarding business operations, our mission remains to deliver peace of mind through customized insurance solutions. This enduring commitment to excellence has solidified our reputation as a trusted advisor in Indiana's insurance market.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Owner Policy
Workers' Compensation
Umbrella Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Boat/Motorcycle Insurance
Renters/Condo Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1949
Highlights and features
- We offer over 70 years of combined experience in Indiana's insurance market.
- Our team provides personalized policy analysis and objective coverage recommendations.
- We partner with a diverse network of carriers for competitive rate comparisons.
- Our streamlined claims process includes simplified reporting and automatic payments.
- Four generations of family leadership ensure ethical service and local expertise.
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies provide liability and comprehensive protection tailored to Indiana drivers. Coverage includes bodily injury, property damage, uninsured motorist protection, and medical payments. We help clients navigate mandatory requirements and secure cost-effective policies that align with their driving habits and vehicle value.
Homeowners Insurance
We offer homeowners insurance covering structural damage, personal property loss, and liability claims. Policies protect against fire, natural disasters, theft, and vandalism with replacement cost reimbursement options. Our agents help clients assess coverage needs and select policies that safeguard their primary investment.
Commercial Auto Insurance
Designed for Indiana businesses, our commercial auto coverage protects vehicles used for work purposes. Policies include liability for bodily injury and property damage, uninsured motorist coverage, and medical payments. We customize plans for fleets and specialized equipment exceeding one-ton capacity.
Life Insurance
We provide term and permanent life insurance solutions to protect families and business interests. Policies ensure financial stability for beneficiaries through death benefits, with options for estate planning, mortgage protection, and business succession strategies.
Workers' Compensation
Mandatory for Indiana businesses with employees, our workers' compensation policies cover medical expenses and lost wages for work-related injuries. We help clients comply with state regulations while implementing risk management strategies to reduce workplace incidents.
People
Tom Plummer
Founder
Established the agency in 1949, pioneering independent insurance representation in Indiana. His legacy of client-focused service remains central to the agency's operations.
Scott Plummer
Agent
Joined in 1976, continuing family tradition with expertise in commercial insurance. Specializes in risk assessment and business policy customization for Indiana companies.
Julia Lang
Agent
Certified insurance professional since 2003, focusing on personal policy solutions. Streamlined client service processes to improve quote turnaround and policy management efficiency.
Molly Plummer
Agent
Fourth-generation team member, graduated from University of Indianapolis. Brings modern insurance technology expertise while maintaining traditional client service values.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, homeowners, commercial, life, and workers' compensation insurance, along with specialized policies for mobile homes, boats, and classic cars.
How do you personalize insurance solutions?
Our agents analyze your existing coverage, identify gaps, and recommend tailored policies from our network of carriers to match your specific needs and budget.
What payment methods are available?
We offer automatic payment options and withdrawal arrangements for convenient premium management, with flexible terms to suit different financial situations.
Do you serve areas outside Indianapolis?
Yes, we serve clients throughout Indiana and surrounding regions, providing both personal and commercial insurance coverage statewide.
How do I file a claim?
Contact our office directly for simplified claims reporting. We guide you through the process and coordinate with insurers to resolve claims efficiently.
What commercial insurance options exist for contractors?
We offer specialized coverage for HVAC, electrical, plumbing, and construction businesses, including liability protection and equipment insurance tailored to industry risks.
