Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
37 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Levittown, NY
Plans Plus Benefits is a full-service brokerage agency dedicated to providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. With over 25 years of experience and offices in New York and Florida, our team specializes in health insurance, Medicare plans, employee benefits, life insurance, Workers' Compensation, and property and casualty insurance. We serve clients ranging from individuals and families to small businesses and large national organizations, prioritizing integrity, relationships, and results.

Our expertise in group benefits spans small fully insured plans to large self-insured programs, and we offer free, personalized guidance to help clients navigate complex insurance systems. Through strategic planning and a commitment to client education, we craft cost-effective solutions aligned with current needs and future goals.
Services
Medicare Plans Employee Benefits Life Insurance Workers' Compensation Structured Settlements Dental Insurance Vision Insurance Pension Planning
Details
  • Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
  • We offer 25+ years of experience in insurance brokerage services.
  • Our services are free to consumers with no hidden fees.
  • We leverage collective negotiating power for competitive pricing.
  • We provide one-stop shopping for personal and business insurance.
  • We offer dedicated claim assistance and billing support.
Services
Medicare Plans
We specialize in Medicare solutions including Parts A, B, C, and D. Our experts provide free, personalized guidance to help seniors navigate enrollment, compare plans, and understand coverage options. With over 10 years of experience in Medicare sales, we simplify complex systems to help clients make informed decisions while ensuring compliance with federal regulations.
Employee Benefits
We design customized employee benefit packages for businesses of all sizes. Our services include small group fully insured plans, large group self-insured programs, and ancillary benefits like dental and vision. With 30+ years of industry experience, we negotiate competitive rates and provide ongoing support for HR compliance, open enrollment, and claims management.
Life Insurance
We offer term, universal, and whole life insurance solutions tailored to individual needs. Our brokers help clients evaluate coverage amounts, policy terms, and riders while considering long-term financial goals. We work with multiple carriers to ensure competitive pricing and provide ongoing policy reviews to maintain alignment with changing life circumstances and family needs.
Workers' Compensation
We provide Workers' Compensation insurance for businesses across industries. Our team helps employers meet state requirements, manage premium costs, and implement safety programs. We offer claims assistance, policy audits, and risk management strategies to minimize workplace injuries while ensuring compliance with OSHA and state regulatory standards for employee protection.
Structured Settlements
We assist clients with structured settlement options and annuity products. Our experts evaluate settlement offers, explain tax implications, and create payment schedules that provide long-term financial security. We work with legal professionals and insurance carriers to ensure settlements meet client needs while maintaining compliance with applicable financial regulations and consumer protection laws.
People
Jesse Peltz
CEO
Second-generation owner with 12 years of industry experience specializing in group benefits and Medicare solutions. Leads strategic direction while maintaining hands-on client engagement.
Arnie Peltz
Medicare Specialist
Founder and industry veteran known as the 'Medicare Whisperer.' Focuses on senior insurance solutions with decades of experience in Medicare sales and education.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide Medicare plans, employee benefits, life insurance, Workers' Compensation, structured settlements, dental, vision, and pension planning services for individuals and businesses.
Are your services free to consumers?
Yes, our brokerage services are free to consumers as we receive compensation from insurance carriers, with no additional costs to our clients.
How do you help with Medicare enrollment?
We provide free 20-minute consultations explaining Medicare parts, enrollment periods, and plan comparisons to help seniors make informed coverage decisions.
Do you work with small businesses?
Yes, we specialize in creating affordable benefit packages for small businesses, including health insurance, dental plans, and retirement solutions.
How are claims handled?
Our team provides dedicated claims assistance, helping clients navigate the process, resolve issues, and ensure timely payments from insurance carriers.