Business Details
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Cambridge, Ohio
Established in 1900, Shafer Insurance Agency has served Ohio communities for 125 years, maintaining a legacy of personalized service and client-focused solutions. As a fourth-generation family-owned business, we prioritize understanding individual client needs to provide tailored insurance coverage. Our team of experienced professionals offers expertise in personal, commercial, farm, and life insurance, representing multiple carriers to ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive protection.With deep roots in the local community, we combine traditional values with modern insurance practices to deliver reliable service through both in-person consultations and flexible appointment options. Our commitment to transparency, ethical practices, and long-term client relationships has solidified our reputation as a trusted insurance partner in Ohio.
Services
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Farm Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1900
Highlights and features
- 125 years of proven insurance expertise in Ohio
- Independent agency offering multiple carrier options
- Fourth-generation family-owned with local knowledge
- Personalized service with in-person office consultations
- Experienced team with specialized insurance licenses
Services
Auto Insurance
We create customized auto insurance plans that address individual driving needs and vehicle protection requirements. Our policies include collision and comprehensive coverage, liability protection, and specialized options like lease/loan gap coverage. With 125 years of experience, we help clients navigate coverage choices to ensure adequate protection while maintaining affordability through multiple carrier options.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions address diverse business risks, offering property coverage, liability protection, and specialized policies for unique operations like dealerships. We tailor packages to protect both small businesses and large commercial accounts, leveraging our carrier relationships to provide comprehensive coverage that safeguards assets and ensures business continuity through unexpected events.
Farm Insurance
We provide specialized insurance for agricultural operations ranging from hobby farms to commercial agribusinesses. Our policies address crop-related risks, equipment protection, and liability concerns specific to farming operations. By partnering with top-rated agricultural insurance carriers, we deliver affordable solutions that protect farming investments while understanding the unique exposures associated with different types of agricultural production.
Home Insurance
Our homeowners insurance covers primary residences, condominiums, and rental properties with comprehensive protection for structures, personal belongings, and liability risks. We offer customized policies that address specific needs like personal legal liability coverage and additional living expenses during repairs. With local expertise, we help clients protect their most significant investments through tailored coverage options.
Life Insurance
We help clients establish life insurance policies that provide financial security for dependents, addressing common concerns about coverage amounts and policy types. Our services include evaluating individual needs based on family status, financial obligations, and future planning requirements. We offer guidance on term and permanent life insurance options to ensure clients create effective financial safety nets for their loved ones.
People
Mindy Eltringham
Owner
With 29 years of experience, Mindy has specialized in property/casualty and life/health insurance since joining in 1996. She has led the agency since 2020, continuing the Shafer family legacy through personalized client service and community-focused operations.
Jacilyn Cox
Licensed Agent
Jacilyn has served clients for 13 years with expertise in property/casualty and life/health insurance. She also provides notary services, combining insurance knowledge with additional client support capabilities to deliver comprehensive service solutions.
Shannon Shiflett
Licensed Agent
As a licensed agent with 7 years of experience, Shannon focuses on delivering personalized insurance solutions while maintaining the agency's commitment to thorough client consultations and coverage assessments.
Laura Walker
Licensed Agent
Laura brings fresh perspective as our newest licensed agent, applying current insurance practices while upholding the agency's 125-year tradition of client-first service and community engagement.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, farm, life, and disability insurance, along with commercial bonds and specialized coverage for boats, RVs, and valuables.
Are you a local, independent agency?
Yes, we're a fourth-generation Cambridge-based agency with 125 years of local experience, offering independent carrier options for personalized coverage.
Can I visit your office in person?
Our Cambridge office is open Monday-Friday 8am-5pm, with evening and Saturday appointments available for client convenience.
How do you handle insurance claims?
While specific claims processes vary by carrier, our team provides direct support to guide clients through policy details and claims submission.
Do you offer online insurance tools?
We focus on personalized service but provide quote request forms and detailed service information through our website for client convenience.
