Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Menomonee Falls, WI
Colonial Insurance has been safeguarding Wisconsin residents and businesses since 1975. As a member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, we combine decades of local expertise with partnerships across multiple carriers to deliver tailored insurance solutions. Our team of seasoned professionals, including agents with over 45 years of industry experience, prioritizes personalized service and a 97% client retention rate.We specialize in demystifying insurance complexities, offering transparent guidance on home, auto, life, umbrella, and business policies. Our independent status allows us to compare coverage options to secure competitive pricing while maintaining a client-first approach focused on long-term protection and satisfaction.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- Client-focused approach tailored to individual insurance needs
- Over 45 years of combined experience in the insurance industry
- 97% client retention rate demonstrating consistent service quality
- Independent agency offering multiple carrier options for competitive pricing
- Locally-based team with in-depth knowledge of Wisconsin insurance requirements
What people say
Professional and responsive
Competitive pricing
Quick claims resolution
Personalized service
Expert guidance
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your property against fire, theft, and natural disasters with customized homeowners, renters, and condo insurance policies. Our coverage includes liability protection, personal property reimbursement, and structural repairs. We help clients understand policy details, ensure adequate coverage, and navigate claims efficiently while balancing affordability and comprehensive protection.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive auto insurance solutions for cars, trucks, motorcycles, and RVs. Coverage includes liability, collision, comprehensive protection, and uninsured motorist provisions. We offer competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships while ensuring clients understand coverage limits, deductibles, and claims processes for optimal financial protection.
Umbrella Insurance
Supplemental liability coverage extending beyond standard home or auto policies. Available in $1M$2M limits, this protection covers lawsuits, medical expenses, and property damage exceeding primary policy limits. We help clients assess risk exposure and implement affordable umbrella policies starting at $125 annually to safeguard assets against catastrophic claims.
Life Insurance
Term, whole, and universal life insurance policies designed to protect beneficiaries financially. Coverage options provide income replacement, debt coverage, inheritance planning, and tax-deferred cash value growth. We assist clients in selecting appropriate death benefits and policy structures aligned with family needs and long-term financial goals.
Business Insurance
Tailored insurance packages for businesses including property, liability, workers' compensation, and cyber liability coverage. We assess industry-specific risks, offer flexible policy adjustments for growing companies, and provide claims support to minimize operational disruptions. Our solutions protect assets, employees, and business continuity across Wisconsin.
People
Dan MacLeod
Principal Insurance Advisor
Third-generation insurance professional with 12 years of experience, specializing in personalized risk management solutions. Graduated from Edgewood College with a business degree, holds 97% client retention rate, and actively supports local charities including Big Brothers Big Sisters.
Jack Larsen
Personal and Commercial Insurance Advisor
Menomonee Falls native with 9 years of corporate risk management experience. UW-Whitewater graduate specializing in business insurance solutions, known for simplifying complex coverage options while maintaining strong carrier relationships to benefit clients.
Don MacLeod
Personal and Commercial Insurance Advisor
Insurance veteran with 45+ years of experience, recognized for optimizing coverage costs and claims resolution. Active community member involved in blood donation initiatives and local charity work, combining industry expertise with personalized client service.
Chris Heller
Personal Insurance Advisor
Former high school math teacher with 36 years of educational leadership experience, transitioning to insurance to provide analytical policy guidance. Specializes in helping clients understand policy details and implement security-focused coverage solutions.
Julie Moll
Office Manager
Licensed agent with 20+ years of client advisory experience, managing policy updates, claims processing, and coverage consultations. Known for exceptional organizational skills and client-focused problem-solving in personal insurance matters.
Questions
What types of insurance does Colonial Insurance Agency offer?
We provide home, auto, life, umbrella, and business insurance solutions tailored to individual and commercial needs.
How can I get a personalized insurance quote?
Contact us via phone or our website to schedule a consultation where we'll assess your needs and provide customized coverage options.
Do you offer insurance for Wisconsin businesses?
Yes, we specialize in commercial insurance packages including property, liability, workers' compensation, and cyber liability coverage.
What sets Colonial Insurance apart from competitors?
Our local expertise, multiple carrier partnerships, and 97% client retention rate demonstrate our commitment to personalized service and competitive pricing.
How does umbrella insurance work with existing policies?
Umbrella insurance provides supplemental liability coverage beyond standard home or auto policies, protecting against catastrophic claims exceeding primary limits.
Can I modify my insurance policy after purchase?
Yes, we offer flexible policies that can be adjusted to reflect life changes, new assets, or evolving business needs.
