Business Details
21 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Cole Camp, MO
Paul Kelly Insurance has built a 30-year reputation rooted in integrity and compassion, serving clients with personalized insurance solutions. Founded on principles of the Golden Rule, we prioritize client needs through professional expertise and small-town values. Our team, led by Noah Kelly since 2021, combines generational experience with a commitment to community service, reflecting the legacy of founders Paul Kelly and Sandy Schlesselman. We specialize in health, life, and senior insurance products, emphasizing transparency and tailored coverage.With deep ties to Cole Camp, Missouri, we actively engage in local civic initiatives while maintaining a focus on ethical service. Our agents bring specialized knowledge in Medicare plans, annuities, and critical illness coverage, ensuring comprehensive protection for individuals and families. By blending traditional values with modern financial strategies, we deliver reliable insurance solutions that adapt to evolving client needs. Our office environment reflects the same sincerity and dedication that have defined our agency since its inception.
Services
Senior Insurance
Health Insurance
Life Insurance
Annuities
Medicare Supplement
Medicare Advantage
Final Expense
Short Term Medical Plans
Disability Insurance
Travel Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2005
Highlights and features
- We offer 30 years of experience in personalized insurance solutions
- Our team provides specialized Medicare plan guidance
- Local experts with deep community knowledge since 2005
- Comprehensive coverage options for all life stages
- Community leaders actively involved in civic initiatives
Services
Health Insurance
We provide comprehensive health insurance solutions for individuals and families under 65. Our agents help clients navigate ACA-compliant plans, short-term medical policies, and supplemental coverage options. By analyzing personal healthcare needs and budget requirements, we match clients with plans that offer essential benefits including preventive care, prescription drug coverage, and emergency services while ensuring compliance with federal regulations.
Medicare Supplement
Our Medicare Supplement plans help cover out-of-pocket costs not paid by Original Medicare. We assist seniors in selecting standardized Medigap policies that provide additional coverage for deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. With expertise in Medicare regulations, we guide clients through plan options to ensure comprehensive healthcare protection while maintaining cost-effectiveness for retirement budgets.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance solutions to protect families and financial interests. Our products include traditional life policies, home protection plans, and final expense insurance. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts to replace income, pay mortgages, or cover end-of-life expenses while explaining living benefit options like accelerated death benefits for terminal illnesses.
Fixed Annuities
Our fixed annuities provide guaranteed retirement income streams with tax-deferred growth. We offer traditional fixed-rate annuities and indexed annuities with principal protection. Clients benefit from predictable returns without market risk while accessing options for lifetime income riders. We explain liquidity terms, interest crediting methods, and tax implications to help clients integrate annuities into comprehensive retirement strategies.
Critical Illness
We provide specialized policies covering cancer, heart attack, stroke, and Alzheimer's treatment costs. These plans pay cash benefits directly to policyholders for medical and non-medical expenses during treatment periods. Our coverage helps bridge gaps in major medical insurance by addressing income replacement, transportation, and lodging needs while maintaining affordability through targeted benefit structures.
People
Noah Kelly
Owner/Licensed Insurance Agent
Third-generation insurance professional leading the agency since 2021. Army veteran with leadership experience in Afghanistan, holds degree from Missouri State University. Combines military discipline with family insurance legacy to maintain client-focused service standards while modernizing agency operations through technology integration.
Shanea Viets
Licensed Insurance Agent
Health insurance specialist with technical expertise in ACA-compliant plans. Native Cole Camp resident offering local market knowledge. Oversees marketing materials development while managing client education initiatives. Brings analytical skills from five-year Japan residency to insurance plan comparisons and policy evaluations.
Charli Craig
Office Manager
Licensed general agent managing office operations with banking industry experience. Specializes in life insurance and retirement account rollovers. Provides personalized client service while maintaining administrative efficiency. Leverages resort management background to create welcoming office environment that reflects agency's customer-first philosophy.
Paul Kelly
Founder
Insurance professional with 45+ years experience since 1977 Mutual of Omaha start. Established agency in 2005 after teaching career. Medicare market leader combining sales expertise with educational approach. Maintains industry recognition through consistent award-winning performance while prioritizing ethical business practices that reflect small-town values.
Sandy Schlesselman
Co-Founder
Retired music educator turned health insurance specialist. Community leader with family dealership legacy in Benton County. Combines teaching skills with insurance expertise to explain complex policies. Active in local food pantry initiatives while maintaining educational foundation support to strengthen community ties through scholarship programs.
Questions
What insurance services do you offer?
We provide senior insurance, health insurance, life insurance, annuities, Medicare supplements, and critical illness coverage tailored to individual needs.
Do you specialize in Medicare plans?
Yes, we offer expert guidance on Medicare Advantage, Supplement plans, and Prescription Drug Plans for seniors.
Are annuities a good retirement option?
We provide fixed annuities that offer guaranteed income streams and tax-deferred growth for retirement security.
