Business Details
48 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Carlisle, PA
Miller Carlisle Insurance Services has been a trusted name in Carlisle, PA since 1978, providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to individual and business needs. Our family-run agency combines decades of experience with personalized service, working with over 50 top-tier insurers to secure competitive rates and customized coverage. We prioritize client relationships, ensuring every policy maximizes protection while minimizing costs. Our team of certified professionals specializes in auto, home, life, health, and business insurance, offering expert guidance through life's uncertainties.With a commitment to transparency and client advocacy, we pride ourselves on being available when it matters most, as evidenced by decades of client testimonials. Our dedication to excellence has earned us recognition as a community leader in insurance brokerage, serving both local residents and businesses with integrity and expertise.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Health Insurance
Business Insurance
Flood Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Workers Compensation
Details
- Year established: 1978
Highlights and features
- We work with 50+ insurance carriers to find the best rates for clients.
- Our team includes Certified Insurance Counselors with decades of local expertise.
- We provide personalized policy reviews to ensure adequate coverage.
- Family-owned agency prioritizing client relationships over corporate interests.
- Proven track record of reliable claims support since 1978.
What people say
Best rates
Personal assistance
There when needed
Lifelong coverage
Quick claims
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect against collision damage, theft, and liability claims while ensuring compliance with Pennsylvania regulations. We specialize in classic car coverage and affordable options for high-risk drivers. With access to multiple insurers, we guarantee competitive rates tailored to individual driving records and vehicle types.
Home Insurance
We offer comprehensive homeowners insurance covering structural damage, personal property loss, and liability protection. Our policies include specialized options for flood coverage, mobile homes, and rental properties. We help clients maximize discounts while ensuring adequate protection against common risks like fire and vandalism.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions include term, whole, and universal life policies designed to protect families and businesses. We provide tax-advantaged options for estate planning and business succession. Certified agents help clients choose between fixed-term coverage and investment-linked policies based on financial goals.
Medicare Insurance
We specialize in Medicare Supplement, Advantage, and Part D prescription plans for Pennsylvania seniors. Our experts explain complex coverage options and help reduce out-of-pocket costs. We provide personalized comparisons between traditional Medicare and private insurance alternatives.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance packages combine property, liability, and vehicle coverage tailored to specific industries. We offer specialized policies for restaurants, construction firms, and technology companies. With access to 50+ carriers, we create cost-effective risk management solutions for small to mid-sized businesses.
People
Kim Shoff
President / Owner
Certified Insurance Counselor with 40+ years in the industry, leading the agency since 2006. Specializes in commercial insurance and agency management. Active community member and lifelong Newville resident.
Thomas Lane
Sales Associate
Health insurance specialist with expertise in Medicare plans and tax-advantaged health savings accounts. Serves York County clients with personalized coverage solutions for individuals and groups.
Allison Mctighe
Commercial Lines Sales
Commercial insurance expert with experience in large account management. Daughter of owner Kim Shoff, bringing specialized knowledge of business risk management solutions.
Amanda Miller
Personal Lines CSR
Certified insurance service representative focusing on personal policy customization. Helps clients navigate coverage options for home, auto, and life insurance needs.
Susan Wyrick
Customer Service Rep
Experienced personal lines specialist with 25+ years in insurance. Former Air Force member known for attention to detail and client retention through exceptional service.
Questions
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Call us at (717) 243-4400 or visit our Carlisle office to receive a personalized quote with all available discounts applied.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, business, and commercial insurance, including specialized policies for classic cars and construction businesses.
Why choose a local agency over online providers?
Local expertise ensures proper coverage with personalized service. We advocate for clients during claims and maintain relationships with multiple insurers to find the best rates.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
While we operate during regular business hours, our team prioritizes urgent claims assistance and maintains partnerships with insurers providing emergency claim services.
Can you help with business insurance requirements?
Yes, we specialize in commercial packages tailored to Pennsylvania businesses, including liquor liability, workers compensation, and construction industry coverage.
How do you ensure competitive rates?
We compare offers from 50+ insurance carriers to guarantee the lowest rates while maintaining adequate coverage for all policyholders.
