Explore 16 Trusted Insurance Agencies Serving Sarasota, FL

Check the insurance services, agency details, and available client feedback for 16 insurance agencies in Sarasota, FL. Use this information to narrow your options and contact agents who may be suitable for your personal or business coverage needs.
Not rated yet
Smith Insurance Group
40 Years
Not rated yet
Smith Insurance Group is a Sarasota-based independent insurance agency offering personalized personal and commercial insurance solutions. Since 1986, we've provided homeowners, auto, flood, life, and business insurance with a focus on competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage. Our team of licensed agents works with multiple carriers to deliver tailored protection for individuals and businesses across Florida.
Homeowners Insurance Flood Insurance Boat Insurance
Not rated yet
Beacon Aviation
18 Years
Not rated yet
Beacon Aviation provides specialized insurance solutions for aviation businesses, offering workers' compensation, hull and liability coverage, and aviation-specific general liability policies. Our tailored risk management programs protect diverse aviation operations including FBOs, MROs, and flight schools. With industry expertise and personalized service, we deliver comprehensive protection designed for the unique needs of aviation professionals.
Workers' Compensation Hull & Liability Aviation General Liability
Valiant Insurance & Investment Group provides comprehensive insurance and financial services to individuals and businesses in Florida. Specializing in home, auto, commercial, boat, life, disability, and long-term care insurance, we combine personalized solutions with advanced technology. Our client-centric approach emphasizes education, transparency, and community involvement.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Commercial Insurance
Not rated yet
Arne Carlson Insurance
50+ Years
Not rated yet
Arne Carlson Insurance is a family-owned Florida insurance agency serving Sarasota and Manatee counties since 1947. We specialize in personal insurance, commercial coverage, and specialized bonds for individuals, families, and businesses. With over 75 years of local expertise, we provide tailored insurance solutions including auto, home, RV, boat, and flood policies.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance RV Insurance
Atlas Insurance
50+ Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Atlas Insurance
50+ Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Atlas Insurance provides customized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses, specializing in risk management and claims advocacy. With a focus on personalized service since 1953, we offer access to a national network of insurers while maintaining a local presence in Sarasota, FL. Our expertise spans commercial, personal, and private client insurance, prioritizing client education and innovative resources.
Business Insurance Home Insurance Workers Compensation
Personalized service Comprehensive coverage Quick claims response
Not rated yet
The Peeples Insurance Agency
41 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
The Peeples Insurance Agency provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions across Florida. Specializing in home, auto, business, and specialty insurance since 1985, we offer tailored coverage through major carriers while maintaining personalized service. Our experienced agents help clients navigate insurance needs with expert guidance and technological convenience.
Homeowners Insurance Commercial Auto Insurance Pet Insurance
Immediate coverage assistance Professional and courteous staff Significant cost savings
Michael Gildar is a Sarasota-based independent insurance agent offering life insurance, Medicare, annuities, and long-term care insurance solutions. We provide personalized service by comparing policies from multiple carriers to meet individual client needs. Our nationwide reach combines local expertise with comprehensive coverage options for individuals seeking tailored insurance strategies.
Life Insurance Medicare Plans Annuities
Not rated yet
FOCUS Insurance Services
33 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
FOCUS Insurance Services provides comprehensive Insurance BPO solutions for property and casualty insurers, offering underwriting outsourcing, claims processing, customer service, and technology integration services. Our U.S.-based team helps insurers reduce operational costs by 15-20% while maintaining compliance through scalable solutions that adapt to market demands. With 30+ years of industry experience and proprietary technology, we enable carriers to focus on strategic growth while we handle core administrative functions.
Underwriting Outsourcing Claims Processing Customer Service
Not rated yet
Insurance Defenders
Emergency
Not rated yet
Insurance Defenders is a Florida-based legal advocacy firm specializing in insurance claim disputes for homeowners and auto policyholders. We represent clients in recovering fair compensation for property damage, personal injury, and bad faith practices through litigation and negotiation. Our contingency fee model ensures accessible legal support with no upfront costs.
Auto Accident Claims Bad Faith Litigation Slip and Fall Cases
Insurance Options of Florida is a local insurance agency in Sarasota offering tailored auto, home, business, life, and health insurance solutions. We prioritize personalized service, competitive rates, and comprehensive coverage options for Florida residents. Our team helps clients compare policies from multiple carriers to find the best value and protection.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Not rated yet
Novamar Insurance Group
39 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Novamar Insurance Group provides specialized marine insurance solutions for yachts, commercial vessels, and recreational boaters. Since 1987, we've offered tailored coverage across the U.S., Mexico, and international waters, combining proprietary risk assessment technology with decades of industry expertise to protect clients' maritime assets.
Yacht Insurance Commercial Marine Mexican Auto Insurance
Exceptional service Competitive pricing Knowledgeable staff
Not rated yet
Warren Middleton
18 Years
Not rated yet
Warren Middleton provides personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Sarasota, FL. With expertise since 2008, we prioritize tailored coverage and community-focused service. Our licensed team ensures clients receive reliable protection and dedicated support.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
Amazing and helpful Professional and knowledgeable Quick and efficient service
Not rated yet
GreatFlorida Insurance
14 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
GreatFlorida Insurance is a Florida-based insurance agency network offering auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance products through 142 local agents. We provide 24/7 service and personalized coverage solutions tailored to Florida's unique risks, including hurricane and flood protection. Our independent agents represent multiple carriers to ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive protection for individuals and businesses.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Insurance
24/7 claims support Local agent accessibility Hurricane coverage expertise
Absolute Pay Trust is a Florida-based payroll and insurance services provider offering cost-effective solutions for businesses. We specialize in payroll processing, workers' compensation, and commercial insurance, combined with HR support and mobile timekeeping tools. Our personalized approach ensures timely, accurate service tailored to local business needs.
Payroll Services Workers' Compensation Insurance General Liability Insurance
Personalized customer service Saved more than $10,000 Courteous and professional
Jason Flatch
27 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Jason Flatch
27 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Jason Flatch provides comprehensive insurance solutions in Sarasota, FL. Our agency offers personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance policies tailored to individual needs. With over 80 years of combined experience, we combine local expertise with national resources to protect families and businesses.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Life Insurance
Helpful and friendly Saved money on insurance Quick response time
Wilde Insurance Services provides personalized auto, home, business, and life insurance solutions in Jacksonville, FL. With over 30 years of local expertise and nationwide backing from Patriot Growth Insurance Services, we offer competitive rates and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual and commercial needs.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Business Insurance
5-Star Rated Agency Most diligent agent Positive results
Bradenton (11.5 mi) Venice (17.0 mi) Englewood (28.1 mi) Saint Petersburg (29.3 mi) Port Charlotte (36.7 mi) Punta Gorda (40.9 mi) Largo (42.5 mi) Tampa (42.6 mi) Brandon (44.1 mi) Clearwater (46.5 mi)